The Scary Untold Story of "Buffalo Bill” of the Wild West

Alphabets Sounds Video

share us on:

The lesson explores the life and legacy of Buffalo Bill, a pivotal figure in shaping the romanticized image of the Wild West through his popular traveling show. While he contributed to the heroic portrayal of cowboys and celebrated diversity by employing Native Americans and supporting women’s rights, his performances often perpetuated negative stereotypes of Native Americans and simplified complex historical narratives. Ultimately, Buffalo Bill’s life reflects a blend of contradictions, highlighting both his influence on American culture and the problematic aspects of his legacy.

The Scary Untold Story of “Buffalo Bill” of the Wild West

When you think of the Wild West, you might imagine cowboys walking through saloon doors, gunfights, or outlaws robbing trains. Maybe you picture famous actors like Clint Eastwood or John Wayne, ready for action with their six-shooters. Hollywood has made the Wild West seem exciting and full of adventure, and we have one man to thank for that: Buffalo Bill.

Meet Buffalo Bill

Welcome to Nutty History! Today, we’re diving into the life and legend of Buffalo Bill, the man who helped create Hollywood’s Wild West image.

In 1869, Buffalo Bill was just 23 years old when he met a writer named Ned Buntline. Buntline was fascinated by the exciting life Buffalo Bill had led. He wrote a series of dime novels about Bill, which people loved to read. In 1872, Bill started performing on stage in Chicago in a show called “Scouts of the Prairie,” created by Buntline. Although he wasn’t the best actor, Buffalo Bill was charming, and audiences adored him. He eventually started his own group called the Buffalo Bill Combination.

The Wild West Show

By 1883, Buffalo Bill’s Wild West show was touring the country with over 500 performers, including the famous sharpshooter Annie Oakley. Calamity Jane, another well-known sharpshooter and storyteller, often narrated the action. The show featured reenactments of Native American raids, stagecoach battles, and cowboy conflicts. Even Sitting Bull, a famous Native American leader, joined the troupe at one point.

The term “cowboy” began to change from a negative term to a heroic image of the American frontier. Buffalo Bill’s show mixed reality with theater, creating a complex and sometimes problematic view of the Wild West. One of his favorite sayings was, “Westward the course of Empire takes its way.” His show was seen as a drama of civilization, where the idea of manifest destiny was celebrated, often portraying Native Americans negatively.

Buffalo Bill Goes Global

Buffalo Bill eventually took his show to Europe, touring eight times between 1887 and 1906. He was even received by Queen Victoria in London during her Golden Jubilee celebration. The show ran 300 performances, selling over 2.5 million tickets. Buffalo Bill’s version of the Wild West reached Europe, influencing what would later become Spaghetti Westerns, popularized in the 1970s by Italian filmmakers like Sergio Leone.

The Rise and Fall of a Legend

By the 1880s, Buffalo Bill was a sensation. His traveling show was hugely popular, and he stayed in fancy hotels while performing for sold-out crowds. The troupe included hundreds of actors, many of whom were real-life cowboys and Native Americans. They reenacted famous battles like Custer’s Last Stand and showcased life on the frontier. However, Buffalo Bill’s life was more complicated than the heroic image he portrayed.

Buffalo Bill was born William Frederick Cody in 1846 on a farm in Iowa. His family moved to Kansas when he was seven, where his father became a leader in the abolition movement. Young Cody worked to help his family and claimed to have held many jobs, from animal trapper to hotel manager. His first taste of the Wild West came when he worked as an unofficial scout at just 12 years old.

Cody continued working as a scout during and after the Civil War, serving under Lieutenant Colonel George Custer. He also worked for the Kansas Railroad Company, reportedly killing thousands of buffalo to feed railroad workers, which contributed to the decline of the buffalo population.

A Complicated Legacy

Despite the show’s negative depictions of Native Americans, Buffalo Bill did many good things for both Native Americans and women. By the 1890s, his show celebrated diversity, and he employed many Native Americans, treating them fairly and encouraging them to share their traditions. He also supported women’s rights and was active in the suffrage movement.

Buffalo Bill’s Wild West show began to lose popularity around 1910 as movies became more popular. The show went bankrupt in 1913, and although he had made a fortune, much of it went into projects in Cody, Wyoming, a town he founded. He died in 1917, leaving behind a life full of contradictions—a champion of civil rights in many ways, but also a promoter of stories that contributed to the erasure of Native American culture.

What else would you like to know about Buffalo Bill? Let us know in the comments, and don’t forget to like and subscribe for more Nutty History!

  1. How did Buffalo Bill’s portrayal of the Wild West influence your understanding of American history and culture?
  2. In what ways do you think Buffalo Bill’s Wild West show contributed to the romanticized image of cowboys and the American frontier?
  3. Reflect on the impact of Buffalo Bill’s shows on Native American culture. How do you reconcile his contributions to civil rights with the negative portrayals in his performances?
  4. Considering Buffalo Bill’s global influence, how do you think his shows shaped international perceptions of the American West?
  5. What are your thoughts on the ethical implications of Buffalo Bill’s actions, such as the mass killing of buffalo and the portrayal of Native Americans in his shows?
  6. How does Buffalo Bill’s story challenge or reinforce your views on the complexities of historical figures and their legacies?
  7. In what ways did Buffalo Bill’s life and career reflect the broader themes of American expansion and manifest destiny?
  8. What lessons can be learned from Buffalo Bill’s life about the power of storytelling and its impact on cultural identity and history?
  1. Create a Dime Novel

    Imagine you are a writer like Ned Buntline. Write your own short story or “dime novel” about an adventure in the Wild West. Use Buffalo Bill as your main character or create your own hero. Share your story with the class and discuss how it reflects the themes of the Wild West.

  2. Design a Wild West Show Poster

    Design a poster advertising Buffalo Bill’s Wild West show. Include key elements such as the performers, acts, and locations. Think about how you can make your poster eye-catching and informative. Present your poster to the class and explain your design choices.

  3. Debate: Hero or Villain?

    Participate in a class debate about Buffalo Bill’s legacy. Divide into two groups: one arguing that he was a hero who celebrated diversity and supported civil rights, and the other arguing that he contributed to the negative portrayal of Native Americans. Use evidence from the article to support your arguments.

  4. Research and Present: The Real Wild West

    Research the real-life events and people of the Wild West, such as Native American leaders, cowboys, and historical battles. Create a presentation to share your findings with the class, highlighting how these differ from the theatrical version presented by Buffalo Bill.

  5. Explore the Impact of Media

    Discuss how Buffalo Bill’s shows influenced the portrayal of the Wild West in movies and media. Watch clips from classic Western films and identify elements that may have been inspired by Buffalo Bill’s performances. Write a short reflection on how media can shape our understanding of history.

Sure! Here’s a sanitized version of the transcript:

When you think of the Wild West, you probably conjure images of cowboys sauntering through saloon doors, weapon fights, or outlaws robbing trains. Perhaps you think of Clint Eastwood or John Wayne, poised with their hands hovering over the holsters of their six-shooters. Hollywood took the intrigue, violence, and lawlessness of the Wild West and ran with it, and we have one man to thank for making that happen: Buffalo Bill.

Welcome back to Nutty History! Today, we’re exploring the life and legend of Buffalo Bill, the man who created Hollywood’s Wild West.

In 1869, Buffalo Bill was just 23 years old when he met a writer named Ned Buntline, who was fascinated by the exciting life the young man had been leading. Buntline published a series of dime novels inspired by Bill, which the public eagerly consumed. Bill started performing on stage in Chicago in 1872, initially starring in a theatrical production called “Scouts of the Prairie,” created by Buntline. Although Buffalo Bill was not a very good actor, he was a handsome guy, and audiences loved him. He eventually organized his own troupe, calling it the Buffalo Bill Combination.

By 1883, Buffalo Bill’s Wild West was touring the country with a troupe of more than 500 men and women, featuring demonstrations of sharpshooting by the likes of the famed Annie Oakley. Calamity Jane, another famous sharpshooter and storyteller, would often narrate the action, and there was even a band named Buffalo Bill’s Cowboy Band. Native American raids, stagecoach battles, and conflicts between cowboys and Native Americans were reenacted. Sitting Bull, one of the most famous Plains Indians, even joined the troupe at one point.

The term “cowboy” began to shift from a derogatory name to a romanticized hero of the American frontier. Reality began mixing with theater, creating a complex and often problematic portrayal of the Wild West. One of Buffalo Bill’s favorite quotes was, “Westward the course of Empire takes its way.” His traveling show was framed as a drama of civilization, where manifest destiny was valorized, and Native Americans were depicted in a negative light.

Buffalo Bill eventually took his show to Europe, making eight tours between 1887 and 1906. He was received by Queen Victoria in London for her Golden Jubilee celebration and ran 300 performances, selling over 2.5 million tickets. Buffalo Bill’s interpretation of the Wild West had made its way to Europe, planting seeds for what would later become Spaghetti Westerns, popularized in the 1970s by Italian filmmakers like Sergio Leone.

By the 1880s, Buffalo Bill was a sensation. His traveling show was immensely popular, and he stayed in luxurious hotels while entertaining sold-out crowds with a troupe of hundreds of actors, many of whom were real-life cowboys and Native Americans. They reenacted battles like Custer’s Last Stand and showcased everyday life on the frontier. However, much of Buffalo Bill’s experience in the West was unique, and while he was celebrated as an All-American hero, the truth about his life is more complicated.

Buffalo Bill was born William Frederick Cody in 1846 on a farm in Iowa. His family moved to Kansas when he was seven, where his father became a vocal leader of the abolition movement. Young Cody went to work to help his struggling family and claimed to have held numerous jobs throughout his life, from animal trapper to hotel manager. His first taste of the Wild West came when he worked as an unofficial scout at just 12 years old.

Cody continued working as a scout during and after the Civil War, where he served under Lieutenant Colonel George Custer. He also worked for the Kansas Railroad Company, reportedly killing thousands of buffalo during that time. While this contributed to the decline of the buffalo population, the meat was used to feed railroad workers.

Despite the show’s negative depictions of Native Americans, Buffalo Bill did many good things for both Native Americans and women. By the 1890s, his show became a celebration of diversity, and he employed many Native Americans, treating them fairly and encouraging them to promote their traditions. He was also a vocal supporter of women’s rights and actively participated in the suffrage movement.

Buffalo Bill’s Wild West began to lose popularity around 1910 as film became more popular. The show went bankrupt in 1913, and although he had made a fortune, much of it went into irrigation projects in Cody, Wyoming, a town he founded. He died in 1917, leaving behind a life full of contradictions—a champion of civil rights in many ways, but also a promoter of narratives that contributed to the erasure of Native American culture.

What else would you like to know about Buffalo Bill? Let us know in the comments, and don’t forget to like and subscribe for more Nutty History!

This version removes any inappropriate language and maintains a respectful tone throughout.

Buffalo BillA famous American showman known for his Wild West shows that depicted life on the frontier. – Buffalo Bill’s Wild West shows were popular in the late 1800s and helped shape the image of the American frontier.

Wild WestA term used to describe the western United States during the late 19th century, known for its lawlessness and frontier life. – The Wild West was often romanticized in literature and performances, showcasing cowboys and outlaws.

CowboysWorkers on cattle ranches who were skilled in herding and riding horses, often depicted in Wild West shows. – Cowboys played a significant role in the development of the American West and became iconic figures in history and entertainment.

PerformersIndividuals who entertain an audience through acting, singing, dancing, or other artistic expressions. – The performers in the theater troupe captivated the audience with their lively rendition of a historical play.

TheaterA place or art form where plays, musicals, and other performances are presented to an audience. – The theater was packed with people eager to see the new historical drama about the American Revolution.

Native AmericansThe indigenous peoples of the United States, who have a rich cultural history and diverse traditions. – Native Americans have contributed greatly to the cultural diversity and history of the United States.

LegacySomething handed down from the past, such as traditions, achievements, or historical impacts. – The legacy of the ancient civilizations can still be seen in modern architecture and art.

DiversityThe inclusion of different types of people, cultures, and ideas, often seen as a strength in societies. – The diversity of the cast in the historical play brought a fresh perspective to the story being told.

SuffrageThe right to vote in political elections, a significant issue in history, especially for women and minorities. – The suffrage movement was a pivotal moment in history, leading to the expansion of voting rights.

HistoryThe study of past events, particularly in human affairs, and how they shape the present and future. – Learning about history helps us understand how past events influence our current world.

All Video Lessons

Login your account

Please login your account to get started.

Don't have an account?

Register your account

Please sign up your account to get started.

Already have an account?