Have you ever heard of the Tasmanian Wolf, also known as the Tasmanian Tiger or Thylacine? It’s a unique animal that once roamed the island of Tasmania. Imagine a creature that looks like a dog but has a pouch, just like a kangaroo! Sadly, the last known thylacine died in 1936, but its story is still captivating.
At first glance, you might think the thylacine is a wolf or a dog. However, it’s actually a marsupial, which means it’s more closely related to kangaroos and possums than to wolves. Marsupials are a group of mammals that carry and nurse their young in pouches. The thylacine had long legs for running and a skull designed for sniffing, making it look very similar to a wolf, despite being so different.
So, how can two animals that are not closely related look so similar? The answer lies in a concept called convergent evolution. This is when different species develop similar traits independently because they live in similar environments. For example, both the thylacine and the wolf evolved to walk on their toes, even though their ancestors didn’t.
When animals share traits because of a common ancestor, these traits are called homologous. For instance, humans and chimpanzees have similar features because they share a recent ancestor. On the other hand, analogous traits are those that evolved independently, like the wings of birds and bats. Although both have wings, they developed them separately to adapt to flying.
Convergent evolution can be seen in many animals. For instance, both dolphins and bats use echolocation to navigate, even though they are very different creatures. This shows how similar environmental challenges can lead to similar adaptations.
The environment plays a crucial role in shaping the traits of animals. For example, a streamlined body is beneficial for swimming in the ocean, which is why we see it in dolphins and sharks. Similarly, a dog-like body is effective for hunting, which is why both wolves and thylacines developed similar features.
The story of the thylacine teaches us that not all similarities in nature are the same. By understanding concepts like convergent evolution, we can appreciate the diversity and adaptability of life on Earth. So, keep exploring and stay curious about the wonders of the natural world!
Research more about the Tasmanian Wolf and create a fact sheet. Include details about its habitat, diet, and unique characteristics. Use images and diagrams to make your fact sheet visually appealing. Share your findings with the class to help everyone learn more about this fascinating creature.
In groups, choose two animals that exhibit convergent evolution, like the thylacine and the wolf. Create a short skit or role-play to demonstrate how these animals developed similar traits independently. Focus on the environmental challenges they faced and how these led to similar adaptations.
Play a game where you identify whether certain traits are analogous or homologous. Create cards with different animal traits and take turns drawing them. Discuss with your classmates whether the traits are due to common ancestry or independent evolution, and explain your reasoning.
Choose an environment, such as the ocean or a forest, and create an art project that shows how animals have adapted to it. Use drawings, paintings, or digital art to illustrate the adaptations. Present your artwork to the class and explain how the environment influenced the traits of the animals you chose.
Research the concept of de-extinction and the possibility of reviving the thylacine. Form two groups and hold a debate on the pros and cons of bringing back extinct species. Consider the ethical, environmental, and scientific implications of de-extinction in your arguments.
Here’s a sanitized version of the provided YouTube transcript:
—
You guys remember Vanessa from Braincraft, right? Tell these people about the animal you just told me about.
V: Right, so I’ve been fascinated by the Tasmanian Wolf, also known as the Tasmanian Tiger or Thylacine, because it’s like a dog with a pouch. Dogs don’t have pouches.
V: Dog with a pouch! Okay, we have to get to the bottom of this. Meet the thylacine, a medium-sized carnivorous mammal that, as recently as the early 1900s, lived on the island of Tasmania. Unfortunately, local farmers preferred their sheep over the thylacine, and eventually, they were hunted to extinction. The last known thylacine died at a Tasmanian zoo in 1936. But that isn’t what makes the thylacine so interesting.
J: So if I was on the island of Tasmania and I walked up to one of these animals, I would think it was a wolf or a dog or something.
RV: It’s actually a marsupial. So are kangaroos, koalas, wombats, and possums.
J: So this is more closely related to a kangaroo or a possum than it is to the wolf that it looks like in its anatomy and shape?
RV: Yes. Fossils and DNA tell us that mammals like wolves and mammals with pouches last shared a common ancestor about 160 million years ago. Another pair with a common ancestor that far back? A hummingbird and a Velociraptor! The thylacine is about as distantly related to a wolf or a fox as it can be and still be a mammal. But just look at them! The posture, the long legs built for running, their skulls built for sniffing, and with massive muscle attachments for biting. Sure, they have pouches, but they look so similar to a wolf! Way more similar than a hummingbird and a velociraptor.
So how is it that two animals, this distantly related, could come to share so many similarities?
RV: There are two biological explanations for similarity. Two animals can be similar because they shared a recent common ancestor. Wolves and coyotes are similar because they share a recent common ancestor. Humans and chimpanzees look very similar because we have a relatively recent common ancestor.
RV: But there’s another explanation for similarity, and that’s called convergent evolution, which means two animals have evolved to be similar to one another through the action of natural selection. For example, me, a penguin, and an ant all have legs. If we go back to the common ancestor between me and the penguin, it already had legs, and they were built a lot like mine. We say a similarity like this is homologous because the trait was inherited from a common ancestor. But the common ancestor between me and an ant was so long ago that it didn’t have legs. Our ancestors and ant ancestors evolved legs independently. We call these similarities analogous.
Analogous similarities are the result of convergent evolution, and one of the most striking examples is in how the wolf and thylacine walk. Think of your own foot; we’re plantigrade animals, so we put our whole foot flat on the ground. The ancient ancestors of the Tasmanian wolf were possums, and they’re plantigrade animals like we are. When a dog or wolf stands, their heel is up in the air. So here’s the hip joint, here’s the knee joint, and there’s the heel joint. So what they’re standing on are their toes. The Tasmanian wolf keeps its heel off the ground and walks on its toes like a dog.
GS: Despite coming from different ancestors, the wolf and thylacine independently evolved this analogous trait: walking on their toes.
J: I’m never going to look at my dogs the same way again, that they’re tiptoeing around the house all the time!
GS: Another example: Take a bird’s wing and a bat’s wing. Homologous or analogous? This one’s a little tougher.
J: So let’s see if I can guess what this is: This is a bat, right?
RV: Yes, this is a bat. This is one of the larger species of bats, a fruit bat.
J: Ha, it also says “fruit bat” right there! I was cheating.
RV: Yes. The common ancestor of birds and bats already had a forelimb, so “having an arm-like thing” is a homologous trait. But using that arm-like thing as a wing evolved independently in birds and bats, so “flying with arm-like things” is an analogous trait. Birds flap their whole arm, but bats fly in a totally different way.
RV: The scientific name for the group that bats belong to is “Chiroptera,” which means hand-wing. So its wing is formed by its hand.
J: I recognize this; this is like the X-ray of your arm. One bone, two bones. Does that mean that’s a thumb?
RV: This is a thumb! So, similarity inherited from a common ancestor? Homologous. Similarity not from a common ancestor? Analogous.
Let’s run down some examples: The human inner ear and a Dimetrodon’s jaw joint? Homologous. Our distant shared ancestor had the same structure. Platypus and duck bills? Analogous; their shared ancestor didn’t have it. A bird’s feather and a reptile’s scales? Different today, but both are inherited from a common ancestor, so they’re homologous. And the wolf-like body of the thylacine? Now we know the answer: It’s analogous. It formed independently, by convergent evolution.
The key to convergent evolution is a similar environment. Conditions like climate, competition, and available food determine which traits are favored. In the open ocean, a streamlined body and powerful swimming tail are effective, and we see it in various animals. Underground, a legless body works well. For medium-sized carnivorous mammals that have to run after their prey, a dog-like body works effectively, so we see it repeatedly.
And these are just examples of similar body shapes and anatomy, but behaviors can be convergent too—just ask a bat and a dolphin. If you speak bat or dolphin. None of these are “best.” There’s no such thing as “perfect” traits. Having a streamlined body is not the only way to be successful in the ocean—just ask an octopus. And having a dog-like body is not the only way to be a successful hunter—just ask a bear.
But even though evolution doesn’t march toward some ideal form, I’ve got to say: thylacines are particularly fascinating. They show us an important lesson: Not all similarities are the same. Stay curious.
J: I want to say a big thank you to Rob; this has been awesome. Thanks for introducing us to one of the coolest, weirdest animals I’ve ever seen. Favorite marsupial?
RV: Favorite marsupial.
J: Mine too!
V: Wow, quick to pick a favorite marsupial, aren’t we, Joe?
J: Ha, what, should I pick kangaroos, Vanessa?
V: I like wallabies; they’re cute.
J: Okay, and thank you to Vanessa for helping.
V: Can we see the pouch?
RV: Only if it’s a female. There it is, right there, there are the folds.
V: Oh.
J: Looks like you guys are doing car work!
V: Of a different kind.
—
This version removes informal language and maintains a professional tone while preserving the content.
Thylacine – A now-extinct carnivorous marsupial that was native to Tasmania, known for its striped back and resemblance to a dog. – The thylacine, also known as the Tasmanian tiger, was one of the largest known carnivorous marsupials before it went extinct in the 20th century.
Marsupial – A type of mammal that carries and nurses its young in a pouch. – Kangaroos are marsupials, meaning they carry their babies in a pouch until they are mature enough to survive outside.
Evolution – The process by which different kinds of living organisms develop and diversify from earlier forms during the history of the earth. – Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution explains how species change over time through natural selection.
Traits – Characteristics or features of an organism that can be inherited or influenced by the environment. – Eye color and leaf shape are examples of traits that can be passed from one generation to the next.
Homologous – Structures in different species that are similar because of common ancestry. – The forelimbs of whales and bats are homologous structures, indicating that they share a common ancestor.
Analogous – Structures in different species that have similar functions but do not share a common evolutionary origin. – The wings of birds and insects are analogous structures, as they serve the same function but evolved independently.
Environment – The surroundings or conditions in which an organism lives and interacts. – An animal’s environment can greatly influence its behavior and physical adaptations.
Adaptations – Changes in an organism that help it survive and reproduce in its environment. – The thick fur of polar bears is an adaptation that helps them stay warm in the Arctic climate.
Species – A group of living organisms that can interbreed and produce fertile offspring. – The domestic dog is a species that has been bred into many different breeds with various traits.
Diversity – The variety of different species and forms of life within an ecosystem or on the planet as a whole. – Biodiversity in a rainforest is high, with thousands of different species of plants and animals living together.
