The surprising reason birds sing – Partha P. Mitra

Alphabets Sounds Video

share us on:

The lesson explores the reasons behind bird songs, highlighting their roles in attracting mates, defending territory, and fostering social connections among songbirds. It explains how birds learn their songs through a combination of listening and practice, while also noting that some innate singing behaviors exist even in isolation. Additionally, the lesson touches on the genetic basis of these behaviors, suggesting that DNA influences the development of brain circuits that control singing, paralleling innate behaviors observed in other animals and raising questions about similar instincts in humans.

The Surprising Reason Birds Sing

Have you ever wondered why birds sing? Let’s dive into the fascinating world of bird songs and discover the surprising reasons behind their melodies. Imagine a brown thrasher singing its heart out. It’s not just a random tune; this bird knows many songs. And it’s not alone in its musical talents. The wood thrush can sing two notes at once, while the mockingbird can imitate sounds like car alarms. The Australian superb lyrebird even has a complex song and dance routine. These are just a few examples from the 4,000 species of songbirds out there.

Why Do Birds Sing?

Most birds make simple calls, but songbirds have a wide range of complex songs. These songs help them attract mates, defend their territory, and build social connections. Each species of songbird has its own unique song patterns, and some even have regional accents. Experienced birdwatchers can tell individual birds apart just by listening to their songs.

How Do Birds Learn Their Songs?

Are birds born knowing how to sing? Scientists have learned a lot about bird songs by studying zebra finches. A young male zebra finch learns to sing by listening to its father or other male birds while it’s still in the nest.

The learning process starts with a sensory phase, where the young bird listens to the songs around it and remembers them. Next comes the motor learning phase, where the bird practices until it can sing the song it memorized. Hearing the song repeatedly helps, but too much repetition can make the imitation less accurate. Interestingly, if the song is played through a loudspeaker, the bird struggles to learn it. However, if the speaker is hidden inside a toy that looks like a zebra finch, learning improves.

What If a Bird Never Hears a Song?

If a young zebra finch never hears another finch’s song, it will still sing. These isolated birds produce what’s called innate or isolate songs. While they might not learn a specific tune, the instinct to sing is built into their brains. These innate songs sound different from the songs learned from other birds. If isolated finches form a new group, their young will learn the isolate song, but it changes over generations. Eventually, the song starts to resemble the songs of wild zebra finches.

The Role of Genetics in Bird Songs

This suggests that some basic information about zebra finch songs is stored in their DNA, shaped by millions of years of evolution. While we usually think of DNA as coding for physical traits, it can also influence behaviors through brain circuits.

The connection between genes and behavior is complex. Genes don’t directly map to specific behaviors. Instead, they code for proteins that guide brain development, forming circuits that control singing. Birds have “song circuits” in their brains that are more active when they hear their own species’ songs. The theory is that a bird’s genes help develop these circuits, while exposure to songs fine-tunes them to produce species-specific songs.

Innate Behaviors in the Animal Kingdom

Innate behaviors, like singing in songbirds, are common in the animal world. For example, monarch butterflies and salmon have instinctual long-distance migration patterns.

What About Humans?

So, what does this mean for us? Are humans born with innate information in our DNA that shapes our brains and leads to knowledge? Could there be some knowledge that is unique to humans as a species? These are intriguing questions that scientists continue to explore.

  1. Reflect on the various reasons birds sing as discussed in the article. How do these reasons challenge or reinforce your previous understanding of bird songs?
  2. Consider the process by which young birds learn their songs. How does this learning process compare to how humans learn language or other skills?
  3. The article mentions that birds have regional accents. What parallels can you draw between this phenomenon and human linguistic diversity?
  4. Discuss the role of genetics in bird songs as described in the article. How does this information influence your understanding of the nature versus nurture debate?
  5. Reflect on the concept of innate behaviors in animals. Can you think of any innate behaviors in humans that might be comparable to bird songs?
  6. The article raises questions about innate knowledge in humans. What are your thoughts on the possibility of humans being born with certain knowledge or instincts?
  7. Consider the example of isolated zebra finches developing unique songs. How does this illustrate the impact of environment on behavior and learning?
  8. Reflect on the idea that exposure to songs fine-tunes a bird’s song circuits. How might this concept apply to human learning and development?
  1. Bird Song Identification Challenge

    Listen to a variety of bird songs and try to identify the species based on their unique melodies. Use online resources or apps that provide bird song recordings. This activity will help you understand the diversity of bird songs and how experienced birdwatchers can distinguish between them.

  2. Create Your Own Bird Song

    Using a simple musical instrument or a digital music app, create your own bird song. Try to incorporate elements like repetition, variation, and rhythm. Share your creation with the class and explain the choices you made. This will help you appreciate the complexity and creativity involved in bird songs.

  3. Bird Song Learning Experiment

    Conduct a small experiment to understand how birds learn songs. Use a toy bird or a speaker to play a specific bird song repeatedly. Observe how well you can mimic the song after several attempts. Discuss how this relates to the sensory and motor learning phases in birds.

  4. Explore Innate Behaviors

    Research another animal with an innate behavior, such as the migration of monarch butterflies or the nest-building of weaver birds. Present your findings to the class, highlighting how these behaviors are similar to or different from bird songs. This will broaden your understanding of innate behaviors in the animal kingdom.

  5. Debate: Nature vs. Nurture in Learning

    Participate in a class debate on the topic of nature versus nurture in learning. Use bird song learning as a case study to argue whether genetics or environment plays a more significant role in learning behaviors. This will help you develop critical thinking and public speaking skills.

This is a song sung by a brown thrasher, but that’s just one of the many songs it knows. It’s not the only avian virtuoso; a wood thrush can sing two pitches at once, and a mockingbird can mimic various sounds, including car alarms. The Australian superb lyrebird has an incredible and elaborate song and dance ritual. These are just a few examples from the 4,000 species of songbirds.

Most birds produce short, simple calls, but songbirds have a repertoire of complex vocal patterns that help them attract mates, defend territory, and strengthen social bonds. Each songbird species has its own distinct song patterns, some with characteristic regional dialects. Experienced listeners can even distinguish individual birds by their unique songs.

So how do birds learn these songs? Are they born knowing how to sing? Much of what scientists know about bird song comes from studying zebra finches. A baby male zebra finch typically learns to sing from its father or other males, starting while it’s still a fledgling in the nest.

First comes a sensory learning phase, when the baby finch hears the songs sung around it and commits them to memory. The bird then enters the motor learning phase, practicing until it can match the song it memorized. Hearing the tutor’s song repeatedly is helpful, but if it hears it too many times, the imitation can degrade. The source of the song matters as well; if the song is played through a loudspeaker, it’s harder for the bird to learn. However, if the loudspeaker is hidden inside a toy painted to look like a zebra finch, the learning improves.

What if the baby never hears another zebra finch’s song? Interestingly, it will still sing. Isolated finches produce what are called innate or isolate songs. While a specific tune might be taught, the instinct to sing seems to be hardwired into a songbird’s brain. Innate songs sound different from the “cultured” songs learned from other finches at first. If isolated zebra finches start a new colony, the young birds pick up the isolate song from their parents, but the song changes from generation to generation. After a few iterations, the melody starts to resemble the cultured songs sung by zebra finches in the wild.

This suggests that basic information about the zebra finch song is stored somewhere in its genome, imprinted there by millions of years of evolution. While this might seem odd, as we usually think of genetic code as a source of biochemical or physical traits, behaviors can also be connected to genetic information through brain circuitry.

The connection is complex and does not simply map single genes to single behaviors. Genomes contain codes for proteins that guide brain development, shaping distinct circuits. Birds’ brains have “song circuits” that are active when they sing, responding more strongly to their own species’ songs than to those of other species. The theory is that a bird’s genes guide the development of brain circuits related to singing and the ability to learn songs, while exposure to songs shapes those neural circuits to produce species-typical songs.

Genetically encoded or innate behaviors aren’t unique to songbirds; they are widespread in the animal kingdom, with examples like the long-distance migrations of monarch butterflies and salmon.

So what does this mean for humans? Are we also born with innate information written into our genomes that helps shape our neural circuits and ultimately results in knowledge? Could there be some knowledge that is unique and intrinsic to humans as a species?

BirdsWarm-blooded vertebrates that have feathers, wings, and lay eggs. – Many birds migrate long distances to find food and suitable breeding grounds.

SongsVocal sounds produced by birds, often used for communication and mating calls. – The male robin sang beautiful songs to attract a mate during the spring.

LearnThe process of acquiring knowledge or skills through experience or education. – Young birds learn to fly by observing and imitating their parents.

InnateExisting naturally or by heredity rather than being learned through experience. – The ability to build nests is an innate behavior in many bird species.

GeneticsThe study of heredity and the variation of inherited characteristics. – Genetics plays a crucial role in determining the physical traits of an organism.

BehaviorThe actions or reactions of an organism in response to external or internal stimuli. – The behavior of animals can change depending on their environment and experiences.

SpeciesA group of similar organisms capable of interbreeding and producing fertile offspring. – The bald eagle is a species that is native to North America.

TerritoryAn area that an animal defends against others of the same species. – Many birds establish a territory to ensure they have enough resources to raise their young.

ConnectionsLinks or relationships between different things or concepts. – In the brain, connections between neurons are essential for learning and memory.

EvolutionThe process by which different kinds of living organisms develop and diversify from earlier forms. – Evolution explains how species adapt to their environments over time.

All Video Lessons

Login your account

Please login your account to get started.

Don't have an account?

Register your account

Please sign up your account to get started.

Already have an account?