My colleague, Hugh, often expresses his concerns about the younger generation’s obsession with social media platforms like Twitter and Facebook. He argues that these platforms have fostered a culture of self-absorption and narcissism. Narcissism is characterized by an excessive focus on one’s appearance, an inflated sense of self-importance, or an unhealthy admiration for one’s intellect. But is the current generation truly more narcissistic than those before, and is social media the culprit?
Research indicates that two-thirds of today’s college students exhibit higher levels of narcissism compared to their counterparts from thirty years ago. This was determined using the Narcissistic Personality Inventory, a tool that evaluates self-love through specific questions. For instance, if someone chooses “I want to amount to something in the eyes of the world,” they are considered more narcissistic. It’s important to note that this inventory measures narcissistic traits but does not diagnose Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD), a severe mental condition where individuals genuinely believe in their superiority and often disregard others’ feelings.
While NPD is a serious concern, narcissism outside of this disorder is often seen negatively. The book “The Narcissism Epidemic” argues that narcissism can be detrimental to society. Time magazine even featured a cover story on the so-called entitled millennial generation, suggesting that social media might be partly responsible. Statistics show that Millennials take a significant number of selfies, with 17 million selfies uploaded weekly in the UK alone. This increase in narcissism seems linked to our enhanced ability to indulge in self-focused behaviors through social media.
However, is this rise in narcissism entirely detrimental? Could it potentially lead to more self-aware individuals? While some may view self-admiration as superficial, research suggests that self-reflection can have positive outcomes, such as reducing cheating on tests. In one study, placing an image of eyes above an honesty box for coffee supplies tripled contributions, indicating that being observed encourages honest behavior.
Interestingly, narcissism is also associated with traits that are generally perceived positively. Today’s college students are more assertive, extroverted, and possess higher self-esteem than those from three decades ago. While extreme narcissism can be harmful, a moderate increase due to social media might be advantageous. Constant exposure to our own image can motivate us to improve ourselves. It’s not merely about vanity; the omnipresence of media and images allows us to perceive ourselves in unprecedented ways.
If we take the opportunity to see ourselves as others do, rather than how we wish to be seen, this reflection might enhance our confidence, honesty, and self-awareness. What are your thoughts on this topic? Feel free to share your opinions in the comments and consider subscribing to BrainCraft for more insightful videos every other week.
Engage in a structured debate with your classmates. Divide into two groups: one supporting the idea that social media increases narcissism, and the other arguing that it enhances self-awareness and self-improvement. Use evidence from the article and additional research to support your arguments.
Maintain a daily journal for a week where you reflect on your social media usage. Note any instances where you felt self-aware or narcissistic. At the end of the week, analyze your entries to identify patterns and insights about your behavior and mindset.
Create a survey using the Narcissistic Personality Inventory questions mentioned in the article. Administer it to a sample of students and analyze the results. Discuss whether your findings align with the research mentioned in the article and explore potential reasons for any discrepancies.
Research and present a case study on an individual or organization that has leveraged narcissistic traits for positive outcomes. Highlight how self-awareness and self-improvement played a role in their success, drawing parallels to the article’s discussion.
Create a visual project (e.g., a photo collage, video, or digital artwork) that represents how you perceive yourself versus how you believe others perceive you. Reflect on the differences and similarities, and share your project with the class for feedback and discussion.
Here’s a sanitized version of the transcript:
—
An older colleague of mine, Hugh, often complains about kids these days with their tweeting and Facebook. He believes there’s a whole generation of self-absorbed and narcissistic people. Narcissism is defined as an obsession with one’s appearance, being extremely egotistical, or having an unhealthy admiration of one’s intellect. Is the millennial generation really more narcissistic than previous generations, and are sites like Facebook to blame?
A study found that two-thirds of college students today are more narcissistic than the average college student thirty years ago. Researchers measured this using the Narcissistic Personality Inventory, which assesses self-love by asking questions with a fourth choice. For example, if you pick “I want to amount to something in the eyes of the world,” you’re considered more narcissistic. This index measures how narcissistic people are, but it doesn’t assess Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD), which is a serious mental illness distinct from simply having high self-esteem. People with NPD genuinely believe they are superior to others and often disregard other people’s emotions.
While NPD is a serious issue, outside of this disorder, narcissism is generally viewed as a negative trait. The book “The Narcissism Epidemic” suggests that narcissism can be corrosive to society. Time magazine ran a cover story on the entitled millennial generation, and it does seem that social media is at least partly to blame. It’s estimated that 30 percent of photos taken by Millennials are selfies, and in the UK, 17 million selfies are uploaded to social media every week. With the rise of social media, it stands to reason that the observed increase in narcissism is related to our growing ability to indulge these traits.
But is this all bad? Could rising narcissism actually lead to more self-aware individuals? While some may view admiring oneself in a mirror as shallow, studies have shown that self-reflection can reduce cheating on tests. In workplaces, when an image of a pair of eyes was placed above an honesty box for coffee supplies, contributions increased threefold. When we know we’re being observed, we tend to behave more honestly.
Interestingly, narcissism also correlates with traits we often view positively. College students today are more assertive, extroverted, and have higher self-esteem than those thirty years ago. While extreme narcissism can be problematic, a slight increase in narcissism due to social media may actually be beneficial. Being confronted with our own image can encourage us to become better individuals. It’s not just about vanity; the constant presence of media and images allows us to see ourselves in ways we never have before.
If we take the opportunity to view ourselves as others do, rather than how we wish to be perceived, this reflection may enhance our confidence, honesty, and self-awareness. What do you think? Let me know in the comments and subscribe to BrainCraft for a new video every other week.
[Music]
—
This version maintains the original message while removing any informal language and ensuring clarity.
Narcissism – An excessive interest in or admiration of oneself and one’s physical appearance, often linked to a lack of empathy and a need for admiration. – In psychology, narcissism is often studied to understand its impact on interpersonal relationships and mental health.
Social – Relating to society or its organization, often involving interactions and relationships between individuals or groups. – Social dynamics play a crucial role in shaping individual behavior and societal norms.
Media – The main means of mass communication, such as television, radio, newspapers, and the internet, that influence public perception and behavior. – Researchers in social studies examine how media representations affect public opinion and cultural trends.
Youth – The period between childhood and adult age, characterized by significant physical, emotional, and social development. – Studies on youth often focus on the challenges and opportunities faced during this transitional stage of life.
Self-esteem – An individual’s subjective evaluation of their own worth, which can influence their mental health and social interactions. – High self-esteem is often associated with positive outcomes in both personal and academic settings.
Reflection – The process of introspection and self-examination, often used in psychology to promote personal growth and understanding. – Reflection is a key component of cognitive-behavioral therapy, helping individuals to understand their thoughts and behaviors.
Behavior – The way in which one acts or conducts oneself, especially towards others, often studied to understand underlying psychological processes. – Behavioral psychology focuses on observable actions and the factors that influence them.
Traits – Enduring characteristics or qualities that define an individual’s personality and influence their behavior. – Personality traits such as openness and conscientiousness are often assessed in psychological studies.
College – An institution of higher learning that provides education and training in various fields, often a critical period for personal and intellectual development. – College students often experience significant changes in their social networks and personal identities.
Generation – A group of individuals born and living around the same time, often sharing similar cultural and social experiences. – Sociologists study generational differences to understand shifts in values and behaviors over time.
