Have you ever wondered what a single brain cell, or neuron, looks like? It’s amazing that we can now take pictures of them! For a long time, people couldn’t see or fully understand the complex network of neurons inside our heads. In fact, some even thought we didn’t need a brain at all!
In Ancient Egypt, people believed that the brain was just a filler to keep the skull from collapsing. During mummification, they often removed and discarded the brain, while preserving the heart for the afterlife. The Egyptians thought the heart was the center of consciousness, a belief known as the cardiocentric hypothesis.
In Ancient Greece, a philosopher named Alcmaeon dissected an eye and discovered the optic nerve. He suggested that there were connections from our sensory organs to the brain, proposing the cephalocentric hypothesis. This idea suggested that the brain was the center of consciousness. He believed that what we now know as neural signals were like “animal spirits” flowing through the body. Other thinkers, such as Pythagoras, Plato, and Hippocrates, also supported the idea of the brain being central to consciousness. However, Aristotle had a different view and believed the heart was the center, thinking the brain and lungs helped cool it down.
Jumping forward almost a thousand years, the French philosopher René Descartes came up with the idea that our nerves contained fluids through which “animal spirits” flowed to our muscles, causing movement. This was known as the Balloonist theory, but it eventually lost support as science advanced.
In the 1820s, Franz Joseph Gall developed the theory of phrenology. This suggested that the mind was made up of different faculties, like self-esteem and kindness, which corresponded to specific areas in the brain. People believed that the shape of the skull could reveal a person’s psychological traits. Phrenology was popular until the 1840s, and the British Phrenological Society wasn’t disbanded until 1967!
As the philosopher Karl Popper once said, “Science must begin with myths, and with the criticism of myths.” If people hadn’t once believed in ideas like animal spirits or thought the brain was just filler, we might not have developed the understanding we have today about the brain. Who knows what amazing discoveries about the brain we’ll make in the future?
Research and create a timeline that highlights the different beliefs about the brain throughout history. Include key figures like Alcmaeon, Aristotle, and Descartes. Use images and short descriptions to make your timeline visually appealing and informative.
Split into two groups and debate the ancient beliefs: one side supports the cardiocentric hypothesis (heart as the center of consciousness), and the other supports the cephalocentric hypothesis (brain as the center). Use historical evidence to back up your arguments.
Create a 3D model of a phrenology head using clay or papier-mâché. Label the different areas with the traits they were believed to represent. Discuss why phrenology was eventually discredited and what it taught us about scientific inquiry.
Draw or paint a representation of a neural network. Use different colors to show how neurons connect and communicate. Display your artwork and explain how modern science views the brain’s structure and function compared to historical beliefs.
Prepare a presentation that debunks one of the historical brain myths discussed in the article. Use scientific evidence to explain why the myth was incorrect and how our understanding of the brain has evolved. Present your findings to the class.
Here’s a sanitized version of the transcript:
—
This is what a single brain cell, or neuron, really looks like. It’s fascinating that we can take a picture of it. For a long time, we couldn’t see and didn’t fully understand the complex network of neurons inside our heads. Some people even believed that we didn’t need a brain at all.
In Ancient Egypt, it was thought that the brain was merely a filler to prevent the skull from collapsing. During mummification, brains were often removed and discarded, while the heart was preserved for the afterlife. Ancient Egyptians believed the heart was the center of consciousness, an idea known as the cardiocentric hypothesis.
In Ancient Greece, Alcmaeon dissected an eye and discovered the optic nerve. He proposed that there were connections from our sensory organs to the brain, suggesting the cephalocentric hypothesis, which posited that the brain was the center of consciousness. He believed that what we now understand as neural signals were akin to “animal spirits” flowing through the body. Other thinkers, like Pythagoras, Plato, and Hippocrates, also supported the idea of the brain being central to consciousness. However, Aristotle had a different perspective and favored the heart, believing that the brain and lungs served as cooling mechanisms for it.
Fast forward almost a thousand years, and French philosopher René Descartes theorized that our nerves contained fluids through which “animal spirits” flowed to our muscles, causing movement. This idea, known as the Balloonist theory, eventually lost support.
In the 1820s, Franz Joseph Gall’s theories led to the development of phrenology, which suggested that the mind was made up of distinct faculties—such as self-esteem and benevolence—that corresponded to specific areas in the brain. It was widely believed that the shape of the skull reflected one’s psychological traits. Phrenology was practiced until the 1840s, and the British Phrenological Society was disbanded as late as 1967.
As Karl Popper stated, “Science must begin with myths, and with the criticism of myths.” If we hadn’t once believed in concepts like animal spirits or viewed the brain as mere filler, we might not have developed the understanding we have today about the brain, or what we will learn about it in the future.
—
This version maintains the core ideas while removing any potentially sensitive or misleading language.
Brain – The organ in the body that serves as the center of the nervous system, responsible for processing sensory information and controlling bodily functions. – The human brain is capable of processing vast amounts of information every second.
Neuron – A specialized cell transmitting nerve impulses; a nerve cell. – Neurons communicate with each other through electrical and chemical signals.
Egypt – An ancient civilization in northeastern Africa, known for its pyramids and pharaohs. – Ancient Egypt is famous for its monumental architecture and contributions to early science and mathematics.
Heart – A muscular organ that pumps blood through the circulatory system by rhythmic contraction and dilation. – The heart is essential for circulating oxygen and nutrients throughout the body.
Consciousness – The state of being aware of and able to think about one’s own existence, sensations, thoughts, and surroundings. – Scientists study consciousness to understand how the brain creates awareness and perception.
Theory – A well-substantiated explanation of some aspect of the natural world, based on a body of evidence and repeatedly tested and confirmed through observation and experimentation. – The theory of evolution explains how species adapt and change over time through natural selection.
Phrenology – An outdated and discredited theory that claimed the shape and size of the skull could determine a person’s character and mental abilities. – In the 19th century, phrenology was popular despite lacking scientific evidence to support its claims.
Myths – Traditional stories or legends, often involving supernatural beings or events, that explain natural or social phenomena. – Many cultures have myths that explain the creation of the world and the origins of humanity.
Signals – Electrical or chemical impulses that carry information between neurons or from neurons to other cells. – Neurons send signals to each other to coordinate actions and reactions in the body.
History – The study of past events, particularly in human affairs. – Understanding history helps us learn from past mistakes and successes to shape a better future.
