Have you ever wondered why some traits just don’t exist in nature? If evolution is so creative and powerful, why can’t humans grow wings and fly? Or why don’t fish have propellers? Why aren’t there five-legged cats or giraffe-sized chickens? And why don’t animals have wheels? Let’s explore why certain traits are impossible for evolution to create.
Many people think that nature can create anything, but that’s not true. By understanding why some traits can’t evolve, we can learn how evolution really works. Let’s start with a fun example from the 1985 movie “Return to Oz,” which featured creatures called Wheelers with wheels instead of hands or feet. This idea helps us understand “forbidden phenotypes,” or traits that can’t exist in nature.
Some animals, like pangolins and roly-polies, can roll, but no animal has wheels as body parts. Why? A wheel needs to be separate from the body to roll, making it impossible for a growing organism to develop. Plus, it would be hard to supply nutrients and blood to a wheel.
In history, wheeled vehicles like chariots were replaced by camels in some areas because camels were more efficient. This shows that the best solution depends on the environment. For example, while propellers work well for boats, fish fins are better for moving in water.
In biology, “fitness” means how well a trait helps an organism survive and reproduce. Birds, bats, and pterosaurs have wings that evolved from their ancestors. For humans to evolve wings, each step in the process must be beneficial. Evolution can’t take steps that make an organism less fit.
A “fitness landscape” is a way to visualize different traits and their advantages. Organisms can only move toward higher fitness, and they might get stuck with traits that are good but not the best. For example, the human eye has a blind spot because of its evolutionary history, and it’s hard to change.
For humans to evolve wings, there would need to be beneficial stages along the way, which is unlikely with our current body structure. Similarly, while zebras might benefit from better defenses, the steps to get there wouldn’t be helpful.
Evolution has limits. For an organism to change, there must be a reason, like a new challenge in its environment. Without these pressures, evolution can slow down, like with the dodo bird, which had no defenses against predators.
Physics also limits evolution. Gravity and the square-cube law affect how big land animals can get. As animals grow, their volume increases faster than their surface area, making it hard to support larger sizes without changing shape.
Some environments, like the ocean, allow for larger animals, such as blue whales, because of buoyancy. In the past, different atmospheric conditions allowed insects to grow larger.
Even though evolution is creative, some traits are missing from life on Earth, like freshwater coral reefs or plant-eating snakes. While some traits seem impossible now, evolution is unpredictable, and they might appear in the future.
While evolution has limits within specific lineages, the overall boundaries are still unknown. The incredible diversity of life shows the power of evolutionary processes. Stay curious and keep exploring the wonders of nature!
Imagine you are a scientist tasked with designing a new creature. Think about the environment it will live in and the traits it needs to survive. Draw your creature and explain why it has certain features and why others are not possible. Consider the constraints of evolution and physics in your design.
Create a simple simulation or a board game that represents a fitness landscape. Use different paths to show how organisms evolve towards higher fitness. Discuss with your classmates why some paths are more successful than others and how organisms might get stuck with suboptimal traits.
Participate in a class debate on the topic: “Are there limits to what evolution can achieve?” Use examples from the article, such as why animals don’t have wheels or why humans can’t grow wings, to support your arguments. Consider both biological and physical constraints in your discussion.
Research an unusual trait found in nature, such as bioluminescence or echolocation. Present your findings to the class, explaining how this trait evolved and why it is beneficial for the organism. Discuss any constraints that might have influenced its development.
Write a short story set in a world where evolutionary and physical constraints do not exist. Describe the creatures and ecosystems in this world. Reflect on how these changes affect the balance of nature and the survival of different species.
Sure! Here’s a sanitized version of the transcript, removing any informal language and maintaining a more neutral tone:
—
Why don’t we see certain traits in nature? If evolution is so innovative and powerful, then why can’t humans grow wings and take to the sky? Or why don’t fish have propellers? Why are there no five-legged cats or giraffe-sized chickens? Why do no animals have wheels? And why haven’t zebras evolved advanced defensive mechanisms to protect themselves from predators?
Today, instead of discussing the remarkable traits that evolution has produced, we will explore the limits of evolution’s creativity and why certain traits are impossible to evolve. There is a misconception that nature is infinitely creative; however, it is not. By examining the reasons why certain traits cannot evolve, we can gain insight into how evolution actually functions.
We begin with a reference to a childhood experience. The 1985 film “Return to Oz” was particularly unsettling due to the presence of the Wheelers, creatures with wheels instead of hands or feet. This concept serves as a case study for impossible traits in evolution, often referred to as “forbidden phenotypes.” A phenotype is the observable physical properties of an organism.
While some organisms exhibit rolling movements, such as pangolins and roly-polies, no animal possesses wheels as body parts. The reasons for this are both obvious and complex. A structure capable of rolling around an axle would be physically separate from the body, making it impossible to develop in a growing organism. Additionally, it would be challenging to supply nutrients and blood to such an appendage.
Historically, the dominance of wheeled vehicles, such as chariots, diminished due to various factors, including the efficiency of camels in certain environments. This illustrates that biological or cultural adaptations depend on the specific environment in which they arise. The best solution to a problem is context-dependent.
For instance, while propellers are effective for human-made crafts, fish fins are generally more efficient for propulsion in water. Similarly, the wheel is not inherently superior to other forms of movement; its effectiveness is contingent upon environmental conditions.
In biology, fitness refers to a trait’s ability to survive and reproduce. The wings of birds, bats, and pterosaurs are modified structures derived from their ancestors. However, for humans to evolve wings, each stage of that evolution must confer an advantage. Evolution cannot proceed through steps that reduce fitness.
A fitness landscape illustrates the variations and their relative fitness. Organisms can only move toward higher fitness, and they may become stuck on local optima, which are advantageous but not the best possible traits. For example, the human eye has a blind spot due to its evolutionary history, which cannot be easily altered.
The evolution of wings in humans would require beneficial intermediate stages, which is unlikely given our current anatomy. Similarly, while zebras might benefit from advanced defensive mechanisms, the intermediate steps would not be advantageous.
Evolution operates under constraints, and for an organism to adapt, there must be a selection pressure that encourages change. The lack of such pressures can lead to stagnation, as seen in the dodo, which lacked defenses against predators.
Physics also imposes limitations on evolution. For example, gravity and the square-cube law restrict the size of land animals. As organisms grow larger, their volume increases faster than their surface area, making it difficult to sustain larger sizes without changing shape.
Different environments can allow for larger organisms, as seen in aquatic animals like blue whales, which benefit from buoyancy. Historical atmospheric conditions also influenced the size of insects in the past.
Despite the creativity of evolution, certain traits remain absent from the tree of life, such as freshwater coral reefs or plant-eating snakes. While some traits may seem impossible, evolution is unpredictable, and what appears impossible today may not be so in the future.
In conclusion, while there are limits to what evolution can achieve within specific lineages, the overall boundaries of evolution remain uncertain. The remarkable diversity of life that has emerged is a testament to the power of evolutionary processes.
Stay curious.
—
This version maintains the core ideas while presenting them in a more formal and neutral manner.
Evolution – The process by which different kinds of living organisms develop and diversify from earlier forms during the history of the earth. – Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution explains how species change over time through natural selection.
Traits – Characteristics or features of an organism that are inherited from its parents. – The color of a flower is a trait that can be passed down from one generation to the next.
Fitness – The ability of an organism to survive and reproduce in its environment. – In the wild, an animal’s fitness is often determined by its ability to find food and avoid predators.
Organisms – Individual living entities that can react to stimuli, reproduce, grow, and maintain homeostasis. – Bacteria, plants, and animals are all examples of organisms that interact with their environment.
Environment – The surrounding conditions in which an organism lives, including all living and non-living factors. – The environment of a rainforest is very different from that of a desert, affecting the types of organisms that can live there.
Adaptations – Inherited traits that enhance an organism’s ability to survive and reproduce in a particular environment. – The thick fur of polar bears is an adaptation that helps them survive in cold climates.
Constraints – Limitations or restrictions that affect the evolution and adaptation of organisms. – Genetic constraints can limit the range of traits that are available for natural selection to act upon.
Diversity – The variety of different species and genetic variations within a population or ecosystem. – Biodiversity in a rainforest is high, with many different species of plants and animals living together.
History – The study of past events, particularly in relation to the development of life on Earth. – Fossils provide important clues about the history of life and how organisms have evolved over millions of years.
Biology – The scientific study of life and living organisms, including their structure, function, growth, and evolution. – In biology class, students learn about the complex interactions between different forms of life and their environments.
