The Attica Prison Rebellion of 1971 was a significant event in the history of the United States, highlighting issues of racial injustice and prison reform. The rebellion was sparked by the harsh conditions and systemic discrimination faced by the inmates, most of whom were Black and Latino. The prison was overcrowded, and the guards, all of whom were white, often mistreated the prisoners. Letters not written in English were discarded, and Muslim religious services were banned. The prisoners were allowed only minimal hygiene supplies, with just one shower a week and one roll of toilet paper a month.
Among the prisoners were Elliott Barkley, Frank Smith, and Herbert X. Blyden. Barkley, who was deeply affected by the conditions, wrote to his mother about his despair, but no changes were made. He began documenting his experiences in a book. Smith, whose grandmother had been enslaved, worked for a meager wage and saw the prison system as a continuation of slavery. Blyden, an active participant in prison strikes, viewed the violence and injustice in prison as a reflection of broader societal issues. They all believed that prisoners should retain their rights to health and dignity and that addressing basic needs could prevent crime.
In the summer of 1971, Blyden co-founded the Attica Liberation Faction, which sought better treatment for prisoners. Despite being largely ignored, they persisted in their efforts. The killing of activist George Jackson in a California prison prompted 700 men at Attica to participate in a silent fast. This act of solidarity set the stage for the uprising that began on September 9th, when prisoners overpowered guards, leading to the Attica Rebellion. They broke windows, started fires, and captured supplies, resulting in injuries to several guards, one of whom later died.
Over 1,200 prisoners gathered in the yard with 42 hostages, demanding change. They organized a medical bay, food preparation, and elected a negotiating committee. Blyden was appointed chief negotiator, Smith as security chief, and Barkley as a spokesperson. Barkley presented their demands to the press, which included a minimum wage, rehabilitation programs, and better education. They promised the safety of hostages in exchange for amnesty for crimes committed during the uprising.
Governor Rockefeller, in consultation with President Nixon, decided to suppress the rebellion. Despite some demands being met, the refusal to guarantee amnesty led to a violent retaking of the prison. Helicopters deployed tear gas, and law enforcement fired over 2,000 rounds, resulting in the deaths of 29 prisoners and 10 guards. Many others were wounded, and some prisoners were reportedly shot after the siege.
Survivors faced severe mistreatment, including deprivation of medical care. Blyden was starved, while Smith endured physical and psychological abuse. Governor Rockefeller blamed the prisoners for the deaths of the guards, but autopsies later revealed that the guards had not been killed by prisoners during the uprising. Despite the tragic outcome, the survivors continued to advocate for revolutionary change. Long after their release, Smith and Blyden campaigned for social justice and prison reform. The demands made at Attica in 1971 remain central to ongoing protests both inside and outside prison walls.
The Attica Prison Rebellion was a pivotal moment that brought attention to the need for prison reform and the fight for racial justice. It serves as a reminder of the importance of addressing systemic issues and ensuring that all individuals are treated with dignity and respect, regardless of their circumstances.
Engage in a role-playing debate where you assume the roles of key figures involved in the Attica Prison Rebellion, such as Elliott Barkley, Frank Smith, Herbert X. Blyden, and Governor Rockefeller. Prepare arguments from their perspectives and debate the demands and actions taken during the rebellion. This will help you understand the complexities and motivations of each party involved.
Conduct research on the broader context of prison reform and racial injustice in the 1970s. Present your findings to the class, focusing on how the Attica Rebellion fits into this historical narrative. Highlight any parallels with current issues in the prison system and discuss potential solutions.
Write a fictional letter from the perspective of a prisoner at Attica during the rebellion. Use historical facts to inform your narrative, and express the emotions and thoughts that might have been experienced during this tumultuous time. Share your letter with classmates to explore different viewpoints and experiences.
Watch a documentary about the Attica Prison Rebellion and participate in a guided discussion afterward. Analyze the documentary’s portrayal of events, the accuracy of its content, and its impact on your understanding of the rebellion. Discuss how media representations can shape public perception of historical events.
Work in groups to develop a policy proposal aimed at addressing the issues highlighted by the Attica Rebellion, such as prison conditions, racial discrimination, and prisoners’ rights. Present your proposals to the class and engage in a constructive critique session to refine your ideas and consider their feasibility and impact.
Here’s a sanitized version of the provided transcript:
—
“We are men. We are not beasts, and we do not intend to be beaten or driven as such… What has happened here is but the sound before the fury of those who are oppressed.” These words were spoken during the 1971 Attica Prison Rebellion by one of its leaders, Elliott Barkley. At the time, Attica prison was severely overcrowded, with a majority Black and Latino population facing constant physical and verbal abuse. All prison guards were white, and some were affiliated with hate groups. Guards discarded letters not written in English and prohibited Muslim religious services. They punished white prisoners for associating with non-white inmates. Prisoners were allowed only one shower a week and one roll of toilet paper a month.
Among those imprisoned at Attica were Elliott Barkley, Frank Smith, and Herbert X. Blyden. Barkley expressed his despair in a letter to his mother, who contacted authorities, but no changes were made. He began writing a book about life at Attica. Meanwhile, Smith worked as the “warden’s laundry boy” for 30 cents a day. His grandmother had been enslaved, and he, along with others, viewed prison as an extension of slavery due to the dehumanizing treatment they received. Blyden participated in prison strikes and rebellions, seeing the violence in prison as a reflection of broader societal issues where individuals are denied justice based on class and race. They believed that people should not lose their rights to health and dignity upon being sentenced, and that resources should be allocated to address basic needs to prevent crime.
In the summer of 1971, Blyden co-founded the Attica Liberation Faction, which compiled a manifesto and petitioned for better treatment. Although largely ignored, they continued their efforts. After the killing of activist George Jackson in a California prison, 700 men at Attica participated in a silent fast. Just weeks later, on September 9th, a spontaneous uprising began when a group of prisoners overpowered guards, leading to the Attica Rebellion. Prisoners broke windows, started fires, and captured supplies, resulting in injuries to several guards, one of whom later died.
Over 1,200 prisoners gathered in the yard with 42 hostages, preparing to demand change. They established a medical bay, organized food preparation, and elected a negotiating committee. Blyden was appointed chief negotiator, Smith as security chief, and Barkley as a spokesperson. Barkley presented their demands to the press, which concerned his mother, as he was close to being released. Over the next four days, prisoners negotiated with officials, calling for a minimum wage, rehabilitation programs, and better education. They promised the safety of hostages in exchange for amnesty for crimes committed during the uprising.
Meanwhile, Governor Rockefeller began crisis talks with President Nixon, who suggested that the rebellion should be suppressed to set an example for other activists. Commissioner Oswald agreed to meet some demands but refused to guarantee amnesty. As warnings of an imminent siege grew, prisoners threatened to harm hostages if attacked. Nevertheless, Rockefeller ordered troops to retake the prison. Helicopters deployed tear gas, and law enforcement fired over 2,000 rounds, resulting in the deaths of 29 prisoners and 10 guards, with many others wounded. Witnesses reported that some prisoners were shot after the siege.
Survivors faced severe mistreatment, including deprivation of medical care. Blyden was starved, while Smith endured physical and psychological abuse. Following the attack, Governor Rockefeller blamed prisoners for the deaths of the guards, calling the operation successful. President Nixon supported Rockefeller’s stance, suggesting that a strong response was necessary to deter activism. However, autopsies later revealed that the guards had not been killed by prisoners during the uprising. Those who survived continued to advocate for revolutionary change, and long after their release, Smith and Blyden campaigned for social justice and prison reform. The demands made at Attica in 1971 remain central to ongoing protests both inside and outside prison walls.
—
This version maintains the core information while removing explicit references to violence and sensitive content.
Attica – A reference to the Attica Correctional Facility in New York, known for the 1971 prison uprising that highlighted issues of prisoners’ rights and systemic injustices. – The Attica uprising became a pivotal moment in the history of prison reform movements in the United States.
Rebellion – An act of violent or open resistance to an established government or ruler, often driven by a desire for change or reform. – The rebellion against colonial rule in the 18th century was a crucial turning point in the quest for independence and self-governance.
Prisoners – Individuals who are confined in a prison as a result of being convicted of a crime. – The treatment of prisoners during the Attica uprising raised significant questions about human rights and the justice system.
Reform – The process of making changes to an institution or practice in order to improve it, often in response to social or political pressures. – The Progressive Era was marked by significant reform efforts aimed at addressing social inequalities and improving living conditions.
Justice – The principle of fairness and the ideal of moral equity, often pursued through legal and social systems. – The civil rights movement sought justice for marginalized communities through legal challenges and public advocacy.
Discrimination – The unjust or prejudicial treatment of different categories of people, often based on race, age, gender, or other characteristics. – Discrimination in housing and employment was a central issue addressed by the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
Rights – Legal, social, or ethical principles of freedom or entitlement; the fundamental norms that protect individuals’ freedoms and ensure fair treatment. – The Universal Declaration of Human Rights outlines the basic rights and freedoms to which all humans are entitled.
Violence – The use of physical force to harm someone, to damage property, or to coerce action, often seen in the context of social or political conflicts. – The violence during the French Revolution was both a catalyst for change and a source of enduring controversy.
History – The study of past events, particularly in human affairs, encompassing a wide range of topics from political movements to cultural developments. – Understanding history is essential for analyzing the causes and consequences of contemporary social issues.
Solidarity – Unity or agreement of feeling or action, especially among individuals with a common interest; mutual support within a group. – The labor movement was built on the principle of solidarity, with workers uniting to demand better conditions and fair wages.
