Today, we have a fascinating discussion featuring Kaitlyn Doughty from “Ask a Mortician” and Emily Graslie, a renowned figure in the museum world. Both are well-known in their respective fields and have been friends for years, sharing a mutual interest in the ethical considerations surrounding human remains in museum collections.
The topic of human remains in museums is complex and often challenging to address. Emily, with her extensive experience as a museum employee, and Kaitlyn, known for her candid discussions on sensitive topics, delve into the nuances of this issue. They highlight the importance of open dialogue with the public, which often leads to questions about the ethical treatment of human remains.
A central theme in this conversation is consent. Many human remains in museum collections were acquired without the consent of the individuals or their families, raising significant ethical concerns. This issue affects not only indigenous peoples but also other marginalized groups whose remains were collected without permission. Kaitlyn emphasizes the need to treat these remains with respect, acknowledging the lack of respect they received initially.
The movement to decolonize museum collections is gaining momentum, but it requires a thoughtful approach. Simply returning all remains is not feasible due to the diverse origins of these collections. The Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (NAGPRA) is a significant step in addressing these issues, mandating the return of culturally significant objects to indigenous communities upon request. However, the process is complex and involves careful consideration of identity and history.
An illustrative example is the Spirit Cave remains in Nevada. Initially, these remains were not recognized as belonging to the Paiute Shoshone tribe. However, genetic testing later confirmed their connection, leading to an emotional reburial process for the tribe. This case underscores the deep connections people have with their ancestors, regardless of the passage of time.
There is often a disconnect between public curiosity about human remains and the respect they deserve. Kaitlyn shares her experience of making a video about a mummified individual, which taught her the importance of approaching such topics with sensitivity. Museums are increasingly adopting more ethical practices, becoming transparent about their collections, and engaging with communities regarding the remains they hold.
Museums play a crucial role in navigating public curiosity responsibly. The conversation around consent is vital, shaping how museums engage with and display human remains. It’s essential to recognize the diversity of opinions among different groups regarding the display of human remains and to approach each situation with care.
Ultimately, this discussion is ongoing, and there is much to learn from each other. Kaitlyn and Emily invite you to share your thoughts on this topic and how we can improve our discussions moving forward. Thank you for joining this important conversation!
Engage in a structured debate with your peers on the ethical considerations of displaying human remains in museums. Take on roles representing different stakeholders, such as museum curators, indigenous community leaders, and ethical scholars. This will help you understand the diverse perspectives and complexities involved in this issue.
Conduct research on the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (NAGPRA) and present your findings to the class. Focus on its impact, challenges, and successes in repatriating human remains and culturally significant objects. This activity will deepen your understanding of legal frameworks in decolonizing museum collections.
Analyze the case study of the Spirit Cave remains. Write a reflective essay on the ethical implications and the emotional impact of the reburial process for the Paiute Shoshone tribe. This will help you appreciate the cultural and historical significance of human remains to descendant communities.
Participate in a workshop where you explore current museum practices regarding human remains. Discuss how museums can balance public curiosity with respect for the deceased. Propose innovative solutions for ethical display and engagement with communities. This will encourage you to think critically about the role of museums in society.
Join an online discussion forum with your classmates to share your thoughts on the ethics of human remains in museums. Respond to prompts and engage with different viewpoints. This activity will foster an ongoing conversation and allow you to learn from diverse perspectives.
Sure! Here’s a sanitized version of the transcript:
—
We have a special guest on our program today, it’s Kaitlyn Doughty from “Ask a Mortician.” I’m so glad to finally be here at the museum with the world-famous Emily Graslie. I’m famous in some circles, but you’re famous in my circles! I think we have a lot of overlap in our audiences. We’ve been talking about doing a video together for years, and we’re friends outside of our videos, but we’ve never shown that friendship on camera.
We went to VidCon together, which was one of my favorite experiences. Today, we’re going to have a conversation about a difficult topic. We reached out to our audiences on Twitter to see what they wanted us to discuss, and the topic that resonated the most was about human remains and museum collections. This is not an easy conversation to have, and historically, it has been quite challenging.
I think people ask about this topic because I work in a museum and have been a full-time museum employee for six years. I have a better understanding of the nuances in the conversation about human remains. You’re known for openly discussing the complexities behind museums and how you work with curators and administration. When you have that open dialogue with the public, they often want to know about the more challenging issues.
I talk a lot about consent on my channel, especially regarding human remains and what it means for families and individuals to have a specific vision for what happens to their bodies after death. Many human remains in museum collections were obtained without the consent of the individuals involved, which raises significant ethical concerns. This issue is not limited to indigenous peoples; it includes many marginalized groups whose remains ended up in collections without consent.
It’s crucial to treat these remains with respect, acknowledging that they were not treated with respect initially. The conversation about decolonizing museum collections is becoming more common, but it’s important to approach it thoughtfully. Simply saying we need to return all remains isn’t practical, as there is a diverse range of human remains in museums from various cultures.
Repatriation is a significant topic, especially regarding cultural objects from indigenous tribes. The Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (NAGPRA) was a crucial step in this process, mandating that museums must return objects of cultural significance when requested by the relevant communities. However, the process is complex and requires careful consideration of identity and history.
For example, the case of the Spirit Cave remains in Nevada illustrates the challenges of identifying and repatriating remains. Initially, the remains were not recognized as belonging to the Paiute Shoshone tribe, but genetic testing later confirmed their connection. The emotional response of the tribe during the reburial process highlights the deep connections people have with their ancestors, regardless of the time that has passed.
There is often a disconnect between how the public perceives human remains and the respect they deserve. I’ve learned that curiosity about human remains must be balanced with sensitivity. I once made a video about a mummified individual, and it was a learning experience for me regarding how to approach such topics with the necessary respect.
Historically, the treatment of human remains in museums has been problematic, and there has been a shift in recent years toward more ethical practices. Museums are now more transparent about their collections and are beginning to engage with communities regarding the remains in their possession.
The public is often curious about human remains, and it’s essential for museums to navigate this curiosity responsibly. The conversation around consent is vital, as it shapes how we engage with and display human remains. It’s important to recognize the diversity of opinions among different groups regarding the display of human remains and to approach each situation with care.
Ultimately, we need to continue this conversation and learn from each other. We’re interested in hearing your thoughts on this topic and how we can improve our discussions moving forward. Thank you for joining us today!
—
This version maintains the essence of the conversation while removing any informal language or potentially sensitive content.
Ethics – The branch of knowledge that deals with moral principles, guiding what is considered right and wrong in human conduct. – In social studies, ethics plays a crucial role in determining how researchers should conduct their studies to ensure fairness and integrity.
Consent – Permission for something to happen or agreement to do something, especially after thoughtful consideration. – Obtaining informed consent from participants is a fundamental ethical requirement in social science research.
Remains – Parts or traces of something that are left after other parts have been removed, used, or destroyed, often referring to historical or archaeological artifacts. – The remains of ancient civilizations provide valuable insights into the cultural practices and social structures of the past.
Museums – Institutions that collect, preserve, and exhibit objects of historical, cultural, or artistic significance for public education and enjoyment. – Museums play a vital role in preserving cultural heritage and educating the public about diverse histories and traditions.
Decolonizing – The process of deconstructing colonial ideologies and structures, often involving the reclamation and revitalization of indigenous cultures and knowledge systems. – Decolonizing the curriculum involves integrating indigenous perspectives and challenging Eurocentric narratives in education.
Indigenous – Referring to the original inhabitants of a region, often with distinct cultural practices, languages, and traditions. – Indigenous communities have unique worldviews that contribute to a richer understanding of global diversity.
Respect – Regard for the feelings, wishes, rights, or traditions of others, often considered a fundamental ethical principle in social interactions. – Respect for cultural differences is essential in fostering inclusive and harmonious societies.
Curiosity – A strong desire to learn or know more about something, often driving research and exploration. – Curiosity about different cultures can lead to greater empathy and understanding in a globalized world.
Collections – Assemblies of items, often of historical, cultural, or artistic significance, gathered for study, preservation, or exhibition. – The university’s library collections include rare manuscripts that are invaluable for historical research.
Community – A group of people living in the same place or having a particular characteristic in common, often sharing values, norms, and cultural practices. – Building a strong community involves fostering connections and mutual support among its members.
