Imagine a world where no one ever failed. We wouldn’t have the magical stories of Dr. Seuss, who was turned down 27 times before his first book was published. Disneyland might not exist because Walt Disney was once fired for not being “creative enough.” And the beloved Harry Potter series might never have been written, as J.K. Rowling faced many challenges before her success. So, is failure actually good for us? It seems so, especially in today’s world where learning from mistakes is highly valued.
There’s even a special event called FailCon, where people who want to start new businesses learn from the failures of others. The idea is that if you don’t learn from your mistakes, you might make them again. But instead of thinking of failure as something terrible, we should see it as a chance to learn and grow.
One study explored whether telling students it’s okay to fail could be beneficial. In this study, 111 students were given tough tasks. Some students were told that failing was okay, while others weren’t. In the end, no one completed the tasks successfully, but those who got the “it’s okay to fail” talk had better working memory. This means they were better at remembering and solving problems, which can help in school. Those who didn’t get the pep talk might have felt less capable, which could have affected their memory and learning.
Instead of telling kids they’re doomed if they fail, we should encourage them to see mistakes as learning opportunities. In another study, students were asked to solve math problems. One group learned the concepts first, while the other group tried to figure them out on their own before getting a lesson. The second group struggled at first, but later they did better on tests, even on questions about topics they hadn’t been taught. This suggests that trying and failing can help students understand math better.
But what about success? A study from MIT found that success can also have a positive effect on the brain. Researchers gave monkeys a task and rewarded them for correct answers. When a monkey succeeded, their brain sent out signals that helped them do better on the next task. This shows that success can lead to more success, creating a positive chain reaction in the brain.
Both success and failure are important. The key is to keep trying and learning from every experience. Whether you succeed or fail, what matters most is that you’re actively learning and taking risks. So, keep going! Even if you fail once, twice, or many times, each attempt brings you closer to success.
So, should we always praise kids and boost their self-esteem, even if they fail? Maybe not. It’s important to find a balance between encouraging them and helping them learn from their mistakes. What’s something you’ve failed at, and what did you learn from it?
Think of a time when you failed at something. Write a short story about it, focusing on what you learned from the experience. Share your story with the class and discuss how it changed your perspective on failure.
Create a timeline of a famous person’s life, highlighting both their failures and successes. Present your timeline to the class and explain how their failures contributed to their eventual success.
Work in groups to solve a challenging puzzle or problem. Reflect on the process, discussing any mistakes made and how they helped you find the solution. Share your group’s experience with the class.
Organize a mini FailCon event in class. Each student will take on the role of an entrepreneur who faced a failure. Present your story and what you learned from it, and then discuss with your classmates how these lessons can be applied to future endeavors.
Keep a journal for a week, documenting any mistakes you make and what you learn from them. At the end of the week, review your entries and write a reflection on how these experiences have helped you grow.
Here’s a sanitized version of the transcript:
—
If at first you fail, try again. If at second you fail, then… you might actually be better than the rest of us. Hey everyone, Trace here for DNews. Imagine a world without failure. We wouldn’t have Dr. Seuss (he was rejected 27 times before his first book deal), Disneyland wouldn’t exist (Walt was once let go from a newspaper for “not being creative enough”), and there’d be no Harry Potter (J.K. Rowling was divorced, jobless, and broke before her famous book series)!
So, is failure actually good for us? Perhaps so, especially in today’s startup culture where events like FailCon exist. It’s exactly what it sounds like: a conference where hopeful startup founders learn about the failures of other startups so they don’t make the same mistakes. It’s a classic idea that those who don’t learn from their mistakes are doomed to repeat them. Really? Doomed? That’s kind of a strong word and may not be the best way to encourage success.
According to one study, which looked at whether there were any benefits to telling students that it’s okay to fail, 111 students were given very difficult tasks. Before they began, some were given a “failure is okay” pep talk, while others were not. At the end, no one was able to complete the task successfully. However, those who received the pep talk had better working memory capacity, which can predict academic achievement like reading comprehension and problem-solving. The study also suggested that those who didn’t get the talk may have felt more incompetent, which could have interfered with their working memory.
So, let’s stop telling kids they’re all doomed! It’s okay to make mistakes; we all do. And if you fail, that might actually make you smarter in the long run. In a study from the journals of Cognitive Science, two groups of students were asked to solve math problems. The first group was taught the concepts and procedures ahead of time, while the second had to try and figure it out for themselves before they were given a lesson. Predictably, the second group struggled with the problems before instruction. But in a post-test, that group actually outperformed the students who had instruction first. They also did better on questions about higher-level concepts that weren’t taught to either group. The results suggest that letting students fail first could be helpful, at least in math.
But before you intentionally crash and burn, another study out of MIT suggests that success might have a more positive influence on your brain than failure. Researchers gave monkeys a task and rewarded them when they responded correctly. When a monkey was successful, the neurons in the reward centers of their brain sent out a signal that lasted several seconds into the next task. During those seconds, the monkeys were more likely to get that next task right too, suggesting a chain reaction in the brain of success leading to more success. No such signal was sent out when the monkey failed.
So, success isn’t a bad thing, of course, but neither is learning from your failures. In the end, what matters more is that you are actually doing the activity you are trying to learn and taking chances. So keep going! Even if you fail, and then fail, and fail again…
So does this mean that it’s better to try and praise kids and boost their self-esteem, even if they fail? Maybe not. Find out why in this video from Julia and Amy. What’s one thing you’ve failed at?
—
This version maintains the core message while removing any potentially sensitive or informal language.
Failure – Failure is the lack of success in achieving a goal or completing a task. – Sometimes, failure can teach us important lessons about what we need to improve.
Learning – Learning is the process of gaining knowledge or skills through study, experience, or teaching. – Learning new things can be exciting and help us grow as individuals.
Mistakes – Mistakes are actions or judgments that are incorrect or misguided. – Making mistakes is a natural part of learning and helps us understand what we need to change.
Students – Students are individuals who are enrolled in an educational institution to gain knowledge and skills. – Students often work together in groups to solve problems and learn from each other.
Success – Success is the achievement of a goal or the attainment of a desired outcome. – Success in school can be achieved through hard work and dedication.
Memory – Memory is the ability to store and recall information and experiences. – Practicing regularly can help improve your memory and make it easier to remember important facts.
Problems – Problems are situations that require a solution or present a challenge. – Solving problems can help students develop critical thinking skills.
Opportunities – Opportunities are favorable circumstances or chances for progress and advancement. – School provides many opportunities for students to explore their interests and talents.
Balance – Balance is the ability to maintain stability and manage different aspects of life effectively. – It is important for students to find a balance between schoolwork and leisure activities.
Growth – Growth is the process of developing or maturing physically, mentally, or emotionally. – Personal growth often involves learning from experiences and overcoming challenges.
