Have you ever imagined what it would be like to fly? Now, think about giving up that ability. Why would anyone do that? Well, some birds did exactly that! Birds like ostriches, emus, kiwis, and penguins can’t fly, even though their ancestors once could. Let’s explore why these birds evolved to lose their flying abilities.
Scientists used to believe that some of today’s flightless birds evolved from ancestors that never flew. This was especially thought to be true for a group of large birds called ratites, which includes ostriches and emus. However, thanks to DNA studies, we now know that all these birds had ancestors that could fly. Over time, they independently evolved to become flightless in different parts of the world, like penguins in Antarctica and ostriches in Africa.
It’s fascinating that birds in such different environments evolved similarly to lose their flying abilities. This is known as convergent evolution. But why did this happen? According to Darwinian theory, changes in the environment either reduced the need for flying or increased the need for other traits. This means nature gradually favored certain traits over others, leading some birds to lose their ability to fly.
Let’s look at an example of how this works. A study in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences examined seabirds that dive using their wings. Researchers found that as these birds became better divers, their ability to fly decreased. For instance, penguins evolved to be excellent swimmers, which helped them catch more food. However, their bodies became larger and their wings shorter, making flying impossible. Essentially, they traded flying for swimming skills.
Sometimes, a lack of environmental pressures can also lead to flight loss. For example, steamer ducks in South America didn’t need to migrate because their environment was suitable all year round. Without the need to fly, they gradually lost this ability. Similarly, after dinosaurs went extinct, many birds no longer faced predators. Birds like ostriches evolved to be better runners instead of fliers, as they didn’t need to escape threats by flying.
While natural evolution played a big role, humans have also influenced birds becoming flightless. Through artificial selection, we’ve bred turkeys and chickens to be larger for food, making them unable to fly like their ancestors. Although humans have accelerated this process, many flightless birds evolved naturally, which can sometimes be beneficial for their survival.
Evolution doesn’t just affect animals; it also impacts technology. Just like birds evolved, technology has changed over time. Think about how dating technology has evolved since before the Internet! What trait would you like to evolve or change? Share your thoughts, and don’t forget to explore more fascinating topics!
Research one of the flightless birds mentioned in the article, such as the ostrich, emu, kiwi, or penguin. Create a presentation that explains why this bird lost its ability to fly, focusing on its environment and evolutionary adaptations. Share your findings with the class.
Participate in a class debate on the topic of convergent evolution. Divide into two groups: one supporting the idea that environmental pressures led to flightlessness, and the other arguing that other factors were more influential. Use evidence from the article and additional research to support your arguments.
Engage in a simulation game where you make decisions for a bird species facing environmental changes. Decide which traits to enhance or diminish, such as flying or swimming abilities. Discuss how these choices affect the bird’s survival and compare your outcomes with classmates.
In small groups, role-play different scenarios where birds face various environmental pressures. Act out how these pressures might lead to changes in their flying abilities. Reflect on how these scenarios illustrate the concepts of natural selection and adaptation.
Discuss in pairs or small groups how human activities have influenced the evolution of flightless birds. Consider both natural and artificial selection processes. Share your thoughts on whether human influence is beneficial or detrimental to these species.
Sure! Here’s a sanitized version of the transcript:
—
Imagine you could fly. Now imagine giving that up. Why would you ever do that?! Hi guys, Lissette here for DNews. Ostriches, emus, kiwis, penguins… one thing these birds all have in common is that they can’t fly. A non-flying bird feels like an oxymoron, but the most surprising thing about these creatures is that they all once flew. They all evolved not to fly.
At one point, scientists thought that some of the birds living today evolved from flightless ancestors. More specifically, they thought this about ratites—a diverse group of large, flightless birds which includes ostriches, emus, and moas. This has since been proven wrong. Thanks to DNA studies, we now know that all of today’s flightless birds came from ancestors that flew, but they all independently evolved to lose their ability to fly. And they did this all around the world: penguins in Antarctica, steamer ducks in South America, emus in Australia, kiwis in New Zealand, and ostriches in Africa.
It’s astounding to think that given such different environments, all these varied bird populations would go through the same type of evolution—or convergent evolution, to be exact. But why would the evolution of flight loss happen repeatedly? Two possible explanations, largely influenced by Darwinian theory, are that changes in the environment either decreased the pressure for flying or increased the pressure to develop another trait. This means that nature slowly selected for certain traits over others, and along the way, took away some birds’ ability to fly.
To illustrate how increased environmental pressures for traits other than flying work in practice, let’s dive into the biomechanical explanation. In a study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, researchers studied different types of flying and wing-propelled diving seabirds. By analyzing energy costs and morphology, they found that as a bird’s functional ability to be a good diver increases, its ability to fly decreases—eventually to a point where flying ceases to be possible. A larger body and shorter wings may help seabirds dive and swim better, thereby helping them get more food, but this body type makes taking off more difficult. In other words, penguins may have lost their ability to fly because evolving to be better swimmers provided a greater advantage than flying, and the two abilities required a trade-off. You can’t be both a great flier and swimmer.
So, the environment puts pressure on birds to evolve certain abilities at the expense of others, but a lack of environmental pressures can also lead to change. If the environment doesn’t strongly require a bird to fly, the bird may lose this ability over time. For example, in a study published in the journal Evolution, researchers argue that steamer ducks eventually lost their ability to fly in part because their South American coastal environment was suitable to live in year-round. The birds did not have a need to migrate, and thus had little selective pressure to fly.
Another example of diminished selective pressures is when the dinosaurs went extinct. During this period, birds were left without predators, so without the need to fly away from threats, the birds evolved other qualities—the ostrich, for example, became large and better suited for running rather than flying. This lack of predation in the environment helps explain why so many flightless birds are found on islands that were isolated for extended periods of time. Why use up energy to fly when you can just strut around?
Now, these changes happened slowly over time through natural selection, but I’d be remiss if I didn’t also mention that humans are also contributing to birds becoming flightless—very quickly—through artificial selection. Our turkeys and chickens would look very different if we weren’t breeding them to be large and meaty for our consumption—so large that they can no longer fly like their ancestors once did. Still, while we certainly have a hand in their flightlessness, today’s flightless birds evolved to be this way, which in some cases might be beneficial.
On a related note, evolutionary change doesn’t just affect living creatures; it also affects the technology we use every day. To find out how much dating technology has evolved since before the Internet, check out this video from our friends at Seeker Stories. What trait would you be thrilled to evolve or evolve out of? Is there something you would trade in for something else? Let us know in the comments, and remember to subscribe so you never miss an episode of DNews. Thanks, guys!
—
This version removes any informal language and maintains a professional tone throughout.
Birds – Warm-blooded vertebrates characterized by feathers, beaks, and typically the ability to fly. – Birds have evolved various adaptations that allow them to thrive in diverse environments.
Flightless – Referring to birds that have lost the ability to fly through evolution. – Penguins are an example of flightless birds that have adapted to life in the water.
Evolution – The process through which species undergo changes over time due to genetic variation and natural selection. – The evolution of birds from dinosaur ancestors is a fascinating example of how species can change dramatically over millions of years.
Ancestors – Organisms from which others have descended or evolved. – Scientists study fossils to learn more about the ancestors of modern birds.
Traits – Characteristics or features of an organism that are inherited from its parents. – The bright plumage of some birds is a trait that has evolved to attract mates.
Environment – The surrounding conditions in which an organism lives, including all living and non-living factors. – Birds have adapted to a wide range of environments, from deserts to rainforests.
Penguins – A group of flightless birds adapted to life in the water, primarily found in the Southern Hemisphere. – Penguins use their wings as flippers to swim efficiently in the ocean.
Ostriches – Large flightless birds native to Africa, known for their speed and long legs. – Ostriches have evolved to run at high speeds to escape predators.
Natural – Existing in or caused by nature; not made or caused by humankind. – Natural selection is a key mechanism of evolution, where organisms better adapted to their environment tend to survive and reproduce.
Selection – The process by which certain traits become more common in a population due to their advantage in survival and reproduction. – Through selection, advantageous traits are passed on to future generations, shaping the evolution of species.
