Why can’t some birds fly? – Gillian Gibb

Alphabets Sounds Video

share us on:

The lesson explores the intriguing world of flightless birds, highlighting their diverse species and unique adaptations that have evolved over time. While flightlessness offers energy conservation and survival advantages, it also exposes these birds to vulnerabilities, particularly from introduced predators. Despite the challenges they face, many flightless birds, such as emus and ostriches, have thrived by developing alternative uses for their wings and adapting to their environments.

The Fascinating World of Flightless Birds

In the lush rainforests of Australia, a diverse array of birds roosts on low branches and meanders across the forest floor, savoring the shade and tropical fruits. However, the jungle is not solely theirs. A dingo prowls in the shadows, its appetite unsatisfied by fruit alone. As the birds flee to safety, the cassowary stands its ground. Unable to fly due to its small wings, it defends itself with a powerful swipe of its razor-sharp toe claws, sending the dingo running for cover.

The Diversity of Flightless Birds

The cassowary is just one of approximately 60 species of flightless birds that inhabit various regions across the globe, from the Australian outback to the African savanna and the icy shores of Antarctica. This group includes some species of ducks, all species of penguins, secretive swamp dwellers, speedy ostriches, giant emus, and tiny kiwis. Although the common ancestor of all modern birds was capable of flight, many species have independently evolved to lose this ability over time.

The Evolutionary Trade-Off

Flight offers numerous advantages, such as escaping predators, hunting, and traveling long distances. However, it also demands significant energy and imposes constraints on body size and weight. Birds that forgo flight can conserve energy, allowing them to survive on less abundant or nutrient-poor food sources. For instance, the Takahe of New Zealand subsists almost entirely on the soft base of alpine grasses.

Adaptations to a Flightless Lifestyle

For birds that nest or feed on the ground, the inclination towards flightlessness can be particularly strong. When a species no longer faces pressures to fly, it can cease flying within a few generations. Over thousands or millions of years, their bodies adapt to this new behavior. Hollow bones become dense, sturdy feathers turn to fluff, wings shrink, and the keel-like protrusion on their sternums, where flight muscles attach, diminishes or disappears. Penguins, however, repurpose their flight muscles and keels for swimming.

Challenges and Survival

Flightlessness often evolves in bird species that inhabit predator-free islands. While these conditions allow them to thrive, they also make them vulnerable to environmental changes. Human settlers have introduced dogs, cats, and rodents to islands, preying on flightless birds and driving some to extinction. In New Zealand, stoats introduced by European settlers have threatened many native flightless bird species, leading to extinctions and endangerment.

Flightless Giants

Despite the energy-saving benefits of flightlessness, many species face a short existence before extinction. However, a few flightless birds have survived on mainlands alongside numerous predators. Unlike smaller flightless species, these giants have remained flightless for tens of millions of years. Their ancestors emerged around the same time as the first small mammals, evolving and growing alongside their mammalian predators.

Birds like emus and ostriches have increased in size, weighing hundreds of pounds more than wings can lift. Their legs have grown thick, their feet sturdy, and newly developed thigh muscles have turned them into formidable runners. Although they no longer use their wings for flight, many of these birds have found alternative uses for them, such as tucking their heads beneath them for warmth, flashing them at potential mates, sheltering eggs, or steering as they charge across the plains. They may be flightless, but they continue to adapt and thrive in their unique ways.

  1. What aspects of the cassowary’s behavior and physical adaptations stood out to you, and how do they reflect its ability to survive in its environment?
  2. How does the diversity of flightless birds across different regions illustrate the concept of evolutionary adaptation?
  3. Reflect on the evolutionary trade-offs discussed in the article. How do these trade-offs impact the survival and lifestyle of flightless birds?
  4. What are some of the unique adaptations that flightless birds have developed, and how do these adaptations help them thrive in their specific habitats?
  5. Considering the challenges faced by flightless birds, particularly on predator-free islands, what are your thoughts on the impact of human activity on their survival?
  6. How do the survival strategies of giant flightless birds differ from those of smaller species, and what does this tell us about their evolutionary history?
  7. What insights did you gain about the role of environmental pressures in shaping the evolution of flightless birds?
  8. In what ways do you think flightless birds continue to adapt and find new ways to thrive despite their inability to fly?

    Activity 1: Create a Flightless Bird Fact File

    Choose a flightless bird from the article, such as the cassowary, penguin, or ostrich. Research more about your chosen bird and create a fact file. Include information about its habitat, diet, physical characteristics, and any unique behaviors. Present your findings in a creative format, such as a poster, booklet, or digital presentation.

    Activity 2: Evolutionary Trade-Off Debate

    Form two groups in your class. One group will argue the advantages of flight in birds, while the other group will argue the benefits of being flightless. Use the information from the article to support your arguments. After the debate, discuss as a class which adaptations might be more beneficial in different environments.

    Activity 3: Design a Flightless Bird

    Imagine you are a scientist discovering a new species of flightless bird. Draw your bird and describe its physical features, habitat, diet, and how it defends itself from predators. Explain why your bird has evolved to be flightless and how it survives in its environment.

    Activity 4: Flightless Bird Survival Simulation

    In this activity, you will simulate the survival challenges faced by flightless birds. Create a board game where players must navigate through different environments, facing predators and finding food. Include obstacles and advantages that flightless birds might encounter. Play the game with your classmates and see who can help their bird survive the longest.

    Activity 5: Flightless Bird Adaptation Experiment

    Conduct an experiment to understand the physical adaptations of flightless birds. Use different materials to simulate bird bones (e.g., hollow straws for flying birds and solid sticks for flightless birds). Compare the strength and weight of these “bones” to see how flightless birds might benefit from having denser bones. Record your observations and discuss how these adaptations help flightless birds in their environments.

BirdsWarm-blooded animals with feathers, wings, and beaks, most of which can fly. – Eagles are birds that can fly high in the sky.

FlightlessDescribes birds that cannot fly, often due to their wing structure or size. – Penguins are flightless birds that swim instead of flying.

EvolutionThe process by which different kinds of living organisms develop and change over time. – The evolution of whales shows how they adapted from land animals to ocean dwellers.

AdaptationsChanges in an organism’s structure or behavior that help it survive in its environment. – The thick fur of polar bears is an adaptation to the cold Arctic climate.

SurvivalThe ability of an organism to continue living and reproducing in its environment. – Camouflage helps animals like chameleons in their survival by hiding them from predators.

EnergyThe ability to do work, which organisms obtain from food to grow and move. – Plants get energy from sunlight through a process called photosynthesis.

SpeciesA group of similar organisms that can breed and produce fertile offspring. – The giant panda is a species that lives in the bamboo forests of China.

ExtinctionThe permanent disappearance of a species from the Earth. – Dinosaurs faced extinction millions of years ago due to drastic changes in their environment.

EnvironmentThe surroundings or conditions in which an organism lives and interacts. – The rainforest environment is home to many unique plants and animals.

PredatorsAnimals that hunt and eat other animals for food. – Lions are predators that often hunt in groups to catch their prey.

All Video Lessons

Login your account

Please login your account to get started.

Don't have an account?

Register your account

Please sign up your account to get started.

Already have an account?