Why can’t you divide by zero? – TED-Ed

Alphabets Sounds Video

share us on:

The lesson explores the complexities and implications of dividing by zero in mathematics, emphasizing that while dividing by numbers approaching zero yields increasingly large results, it does not equate to dividing by zero itself, which is undefined. It delves into the concept of multiplicative inverses, explaining that zero lacks an inverse, making division by zero impossible. The lesson encourages pushing mathematical boundaries and considering alternative frameworks, such as the Riemann sphere, to understand these challenges better.

The Intriguing World of Division by Zero

In the realm of mathematics, altering the rules can lead to fascinating outcomes. However, one rule that is often emphasized as unbreakable is the prohibition against dividing by zero. But why does this seemingly simple operation cause such perplexing issues?

Understanding Division and Its Limits

Typically, as we divide by progressively smaller numbers, the results become increasingly larger. For instance, dividing ten by two yields five, by one gives ten, and by one-millionth results in ten million. This pattern suggests that dividing by numbers approaching zero could lead to an answer that grows infinitely large. So, does this mean that ten divided by zero equals infinity?

While this might seem logical, it is not accurate to claim that ten divided by zero equals infinity. What we can assert is that dividing ten by a number approaching zero results in an answer that trends towards infinity. However, this is not equivalent to stating that the division by zero itself equals infinity.

The Concept of Multiplicative Inverses

To comprehend why dividing by zero is problematic, we must delve into the essence of division. Division can be viewed as the inverse of multiplication. For example, ten divided by two can be interpreted as “how many times must we add two to reach ten?” or “two times what equals ten?”

In mathematical terms, if we multiply a number by another number, say x, we can seek a new number to multiply by to return to the original number. This new number is known as the multiplicative inverse of x. For instance, multiplying three by two gives six, and multiplying by one-half returns us to three. Thus, the multiplicative inverse of two is one-half, and for ten, it is one-tenth. The product of any number and its multiplicative inverse is always one.

The Impossibility of Zero’s Multiplicative Inverse

To divide by zero, we would need to identify its multiplicative inverse, which would be one over zero. This would imply that multiplying this inverse by zero should yield one. However, since any number multiplied by zero remains zero, such a number cannot exist. Consequently, zero lacks a multiplicative inverse.

Exploring Mathematical Boundaries

Despite this, mathematicians have historically challenged established rules. For instance, the concept of taking the square root of negative numbers was once deemed impossible until the introduction of the imaginary unit i, which represents the square root of negative one. This innovation paved the way for the complex number system.

Could we similarly redefine division by zero by introducing a new rule, such as defining infinity as one over zero? If we attempt this, zero times infinity would equal one. However, this leads to contradictions, such as zero times infinity plus zero times infinity equating to two, which implies one equals two. This paradox highlights the inconsistency of such a definition within our conventional number system.

The Riemann Sphere and Beyond

Interestingly, there exists a mathematical construct known as the Riemann sphere, which addresses division by zero through an alternative approach. However, this topic is complex and warrants separate exploration.

In conclusion, while dividing by zero in the most straightforward manner presents challenges, it should not deter us from pushing mathematical boundaries. By daring to experiment and redefine rules, we open the door to discovering new mathematical landscapes and possibilities.

  1. What new insights did you gain about the concept of division by zero from the article?
  2. How does the explanation of multiplicative inverses enhance your understanding of why division by zero is problematic?
  3. Reflect on the historical context provided in the article. How do you think challenging established mathematical rules can lead to new discoveries?
  4. In what ways does the article encourage you to think differently about mathematical boundaries and possibilities?
  5. How does the concept of the Riemann sphere intrigue you, and what questions does it raise about alternative mathematical approaches?
  6. Consider the paradox presented when attempting to define infinity as one over zero. How does this challenge your understanding of mathematical consistency?
  7. What parallels can you draw between the introduction of the imaginary unit and the potential redefinition of division by zero?
  8. How might the ideas discussed in the article influence your perspective on the role of creativity and innovation in mathematics?
  1. Interactive Graphing Activity

    Use graphing software or an online graphing calculator to explore the behavior of functions as they approach division by zero. Plot the function f(x) = 10/x and observe what happens as x approaches zero from both the positive and negative sides. Discuss your observations with your classmates and write a brief summary of what you learned about the behavior of the function near zero.

  2. Group Discussion on Multiplicative Inverses

    Form small groups and discuss the concept of multiplicative inverses. Each group should come up with examples of numbers and their multiplicative inverses. Then, try to explain why zero does not have a multiplicative inverse. Present your findings to the class and engage in a discussion about the implications of this in mathematics.

  3. Historical Exploration of Mathematical Concepts

    Research the historical development of mathematical concepts that were once considered impossible, such as the introduction of imaginary numbers. Write a short essay on how these concepts were eventually accepted and how they have impacted modern mathematics. Reflect on whether a similar breakthrough could happen with division by zero.

  4. Creative Problem-Solving Workshop

    Participate in a workshop where you brainstorm and propose new mathematical rules or systems that could potentially allow for division by zero. Work in teams to develop your ideas and present them to the class. Discuss the potential benefits and drawbacks of your proposed systems and how they might address the paradoxes mentioned in the article.

  5. Exploring the Riemann Sphere

    Delve into the concept of the Riemann sphere and how it addresses division by zero. Create a visual representation of the Riemann sphere and explain its significance in mathematics. Present your findings to the class and discuss how this advanced concept provides an alternative approach to dealing with division by zero.

DivisionThe operation of determining how many times one number is contained within another. – Example sentence: In algebra, division is used to simplify expressions by dividing both sides of an equation by the same non-zero number.

ZeroThe integer that represents a null quantity in mathematics, often used as a placeholder in positional notation. – Example sentence: The zero of a function is the value of x that makes the function equal to zero.

MultiplicativeRelating to multiplication; often used to describe properties or identities involving multiplication. – Example sentence: The multiplicative identity in algebra is the number 1, as multiplying any number by 1 leaves it unchanged.

InverseAn element that, when combined with another element in an operation, results in the identity element of that operation. – Example sentence: The multiplicative inverse of a number is its reciprocal, which when multiplied together, equals 1.

InfinityA concept in mathematics that describes something without any bound or larger than any natural number. – Example sentence: In calculus, limits can approach infinity, indicating that a function grows without bound.

NumbersMathematical objects used to count, measure, and label. – Example sentence: Real numbers include both rational and irrational numbers, forming a complete set for algebraic operations.

MathematicalRelating to mathematics; involving or characterized by the precise use of numbers and symbols. – Example sentence: Mathematical models are used to represent real-world phenomena in a structured and quantifiable way.

ComplexInvolving numbers that have both a real and an imaginary part. – Example sentence: Complex numbers are used in algebra to solve equations that have no real solutions.

SystemA set of equations or inequalities that are solved together. – Example sentence: Solving a system of linear equations can be done using methods such as substitution or elimination.

BoundariesLimits or borders that define the scope of a mathematical problem or set. – Example sentence: In calculus, boundaries are used to define the region over which an integral is evaluated.

All Video Lessons

Login your account

Please login your account to get started.

Don't have an account?

Register your account

Please sign up your account to get started.

Already have an account?