Have you ever noticed the small pinkish bump in the corner of your eye? This is actually a leftover from a third eyelid, known as the “plica semilunaris.” In birds and some mammals, this third eyelid acts like a windshield wiper, helping to keep dust and debris out of their eyes. However, in humans, it doesn’t serve this purpose anymore. It’s considered vestigial, which means it no longer has its original function.
Vestigial structures are parts of the body that have lost their original function through evolution. Many of these structures were passed down from our ancestors long before modern humans existed. But why do they stick around if they’re not useful? To understand this, we need to look at natural selection.
Natural selection is a process where traits that help an organism survive and reproduce are more likely to be passed on to the next generation. As environments change, some traits that were once useful can become less helpful. These traits might gradually disappear if they become a disadvantage. However, if a trait isn’t harmful, it might not be selected against and can remain, even if it’s not useful anymore.
One example of a vestigial structure is the tailbone. Scientists believe that as the climate changed and grasslands appeared, our tail-bearing ancestors moved from the trees to the ground. Tails, which were helpful in trees, became a hindrance on land. Over millions of years, individuals with shorter tails were more successful, and eventually, our ancestors lost their external tails. Today, human embryos still develop tails that dissolve as they grow, but the tailbone remains because it doesn’t cause harm and serves as an anchor for some muscles.
Another example is the palmaris longus muscle. Up to 85% of people have this vestigial muscle. To see if you have it, place your hand flat and touch your pinkie to your thumb. If a band pops up in your wrist, that’s the tendon of this now-unused muscle. Not everyone has it, which helps us understand its past function. In our primate relatives, this muscle is sometimes absent in those that spend more time on land but always present in those that live in trees, suggesting it helped with swinging from branches.
The appendix is another vestigial structure. It might have been part of our ancestors’ digestive system for breaking down plant materials. As diets changed, this part of the system shrank. Unlike other vestigial structures, the appendix can become inflamed and cause serious health issues. Despite this, it has persisted, possibly because it serves as a reservoir for beneficial bacteria. However, the exact reason for its persistence is still unclear.
Evolution is not a perfect process. Humans are the result of millions of years of trial, error, and random chance. We carry many evolutionary relics that remind us of our journey through time. These vestigial structures are fascinating glimpses into our past, showing how our bodies have adapted and changed over millions of years.
Using clay or modeling materials, create a 3D model of a vestigial structure, such as the appendix or the tailbone. Research its original function and present your model to the class, explaining how this structure has evolved over time and why it is considered vestigial today.
Work in pairs to find and list as many vestigial structures as you can in humans and other animals. Use online resources or library books to help you. Once you’ve compiled your list, share your findings with the class and discuss why these structures might have persisted through evolution.
Participate in a class debate about the appendix. Divide into two groups: one arguing that the appendix has a beneficial role in modern humans, and the other arguing that it is a useless vestigial structure. Use scientific evidence to support your arguments and engage in a respectful discussion.
Engage in a simulation game that demonstrates natural selection. Use different colored beads to represent various traits in a population. Simulate environmental changes and observe how certain traits become more or less common over generations. Discuss how this activity relates to the persistence of vestigial structures.
Choose an evolutionary relic or vestigial structure not mentioned in the article, research its history and significance, and create a presentation. Include visuals and explain how this structure provides insight into the evolutionary history of the species it belongs to.
Here’s a sanitized version of the transcript:
—
You know that small pink structure nestled in the corner of your eye? It’s actually the remnant of a third eyelid. Known as the “plica semilunaris,” it’s much more prominent in birds and some mammals, functioning like a windshield wiper to keep dust and debris out of their eyes. However, in humans, it doesn’t serve that purpose. It’s considered vestigial, meaning it no longer has its original function.
There are several other vestigial structures in the human body, many of which became vestigial long before Homo sapiens existed, passing down from one of our ancestor species to the next. But why have they persisted for so long? To answer this, it helps to understand natural selection. Natural selection means that traits which help an organism survive and reproduce in a given environment are more likely to be passed on to the next generation. As environments change, traits that were once useful can become less advantageous. Those traits are often selected against, gradually disappearing from the population. However, if a trait isn’t actively harmful, it might not be selected against and can remain, even if it’s not useful.
Take the tailbone, for example. Evolutionary biologists believe that as the climate became drier and grasslands emerged, our tail-bearing ancestors left the trees and began walking on land. The tails that had helped them in the trees began to hinder their ability to walk. Individuals with mutations that reduced tail length became more successful on land, surviving long enough to pass their shorter tails to the next generation. This change likely occurred gradually over millions of years until, about 20 million years ago, our ancestors’ external tails disappeared entirely. Today, we know that human embryos have tails that dissolve as they develop, but the stubby tailbone remains, likely because it doesn’t cause any harm—in fact, it serves a minor function as an anchor point for certain muscles.
Up to 85% of people have a vestigial muscle called the “palmaris longus.” To check if you have it, place your hand flat on a surface and touch your pinkie to your thumb. If you see a little band pop up in the middle of your wrist, that’s the tendon that attaches to this now-defunct muscle. The fact that not everyone has it has helped us trace its function. Vestigial traits can persist when there’s no incentive to lose them, but since there’s also no incentive to keep them, random mutations can sometimes eliminate them from part of the population.
Looking at our primate relatives, we see that the palmaris longus is sometimes absent in those that spend more time on land but always present in those that spend more time in trees. This suggests it used to help us swing from branch to branch and became unnecessary when we adapted to life on land.
The appendix may have once been part of the intestinal system our ancestors used for digesting plant materials. As their diets changed, those parts of the intestinal system began to shrink. Unlike other vestigial structures, though, the appendix isn’t always harmless—it can become dangerously inflamed. For most of human history, a burst appendix could be fatal. So why has it remained? It’s possible that it was very slowly on its way out, or that mutations simply hadn’t occurred to make it smaller. Alternatively, it might still have benefits, such as serving as a reservoir of bacteria that helps us break down food. However, the exact reason for the appendix’s persistence remains unclear.
Evolution is an imperfect process. Human beings are the result of millions of years of trial, error, and random chance—and we carry many evolutionary relics that remind us of this journey.
—
This version maintains the informative content while removing any informal language or unnecessary details.
Third Eyelid – A translucent or transparent eyelid present in some animals that can be drawn across the eye for protection and to moisten it while maintaining visibility. – In some animals, the third eyelid helps protect the eye from dust and debris.
Vestigial – Referring to a body part or organ that has lost its original function through the course of evolution. – The human appendix is considered a vestigial organ because it no longer plays a significant role in digestion.
Structures – Physical features of an organism that have specific forms and functions, often shaped by evolutionary processes. – The wings of birds and the flippers of dolphins are examples of structures adapted for different environments.
Evolution – The process by which different kinds of living organisms have developed and diversified from earlier forms during the history of the Earth. – Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution explains how species change over time through natural selection.
Natural Selection – The process by which organisms better adapted to their environment tend to survive and produce more offspring. – Natural selection can lead to the development of new species as advantageous traits become more common in a population.
Traits – Characteristics or features of an organism that can be inherited, influenced by the environment, or a combination of both. – Eye color and leaf shape are examples of traits that can be passed from one generation to the next.
Ancestors – Organisms from which others have descended, often referring to earlier forms in the evolutionary history of a species. – Humans and chimpanzees share a common ancestor that lived millions of years ago.
Tailbone – A small, triangular bone at the base of the human spine, considered a vestigial structure from when our ancestors had tails. – The tailbone, or coccyx, is a remnant of a tail that was present in our distant ancestors.
Appendix – A small, tube-like organ attached to the large intestine in humans, often considered vestigial. – Although the appendix is not essential for digestion, it may play a role in the immune system.
Muscles – Tissues in the body that have the ability to contract and produce movement or maintain the position of parts of the body. – The muscles in a bird’s wings are specially adapted for flight, allowing them to soar and maneuver in the air.
