Have you ever noticed that many animals, like caterpillars, kangaroos, stingrays, and seagulls, have a darker color on top and a lighter color underneath? This pattern is common in animals all over the world, whether they are hunters or the hunted, and no matter where they live.
Back in the 1800s, scientists were curious about why so many animals had this shading pattern. Then, in the early 1900s, an American painter named Abbott Thayer came up with an interesting idea. He thought that this pattern helped animals hide from predators. Thayer, who knew a lot about how shadows work in art, realized that the colors on animals could cancel out the shadows their bodies cast in the sunlight.
For example, a wolf has a dark top coat that fades to a lighter color underneath. When sunlight hits the wolf, the top part is bright, and the lighter belly is in shadow, making the wolf’s color look even. Thayer called this “obliterate shading” and believed it helped animals blend into their surroundings.
Thayer tested his idea by painting wooden birds with darker tops and lighter undersides. He showed how these painted birds could disappear against their natural backgrounds. Although he thought almost all animal colors were for camouflage, some of his ideas, like flamingos blending into sunsets, were a bit off.
Today, we call this pattern “counter shading,” and it’s widely accepted as a form of camouflage. Some animals, like certain caterpillars that hang upside down, have reverse counter shading to help them blend in when in their usual position.
Research shows that counter shading is more noticeable in bright environments, where it helps balance strong shadows. Paleontologists have even found evidence of counter shading in dinosaur fossils! However, scientists are still exploring how universal this trait is.
Studies suggest that counter shading helps animals avoid being seen by reducing contrast, making them less visible to predators. Interestingly, not all animals see the world like humans do, so counter shading might work even if it doesn’t completely hide an animal.
For animals in the water, counter shading might serve a different purpose. Since they can be seen from different angles, it helps them blend into various backgrounds. For example, a fish’s light belly hides it against bright water, while its dark top blends with deeper waters.
Some sea creatures have developed a trick called counter illumination. They produce light on their undersides to hide their silhouettes when viewed from below.
While we understand some aspects of counter shading, its functions can vary among species. For instance, penguins use their coloration not only for camouflage but also to regulate their temperature by absorbing sunlight.
Both predators and prey are always evolving new ways to outsmart each other. Counter shading has been so effective that it has appeared in nature for millions of years, showing the amazing connection between art and science.
If you’re curious about learning more, check out Brilliant, an online platform with interactive lessons in science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM). They offer courses that teach problem-solving through fun activities. For example, their computational biology course combines computer science with biology, helping students solve important problems in the field.
To learn more about Brilliant, visit brilliant.org/besmart.
Use your creativity to design an animal with counter shading. Draw or paint your animal, showing how its coloration helps it blend into its environment. Consider the habitat and lighting conditions your animal might encounter. Share your artwork with the class and explain how counter shading helps your animal stay hidden.
Conduct an experiment to see how shadows affect visibility. Use a flashlight and small objects with different colors to simulate sunlight. Observe how the shadows change when you adjust the light source. Discuss how counter shading might help animals in similar lighting conditions.
Participate in a role-playing game where you take on the role of either a predator or prey. Use props or costumes to represent different animals with counter shading. Discuss strategies for hiding or hunting, and how counter shading plays a role in survival.
Choose an animal that uses counter shading and research its habitat, behavior, and predators. Create a presentation to share your findings with the class. Highlight how counter shading benefits the animal in its natural environment.
Explore an online lesson about counter shading on platforms like Brilliant. Engage with interactive activities that demonstrate the principles of camouflage and counter shading. Reflect on what you learned and discuss how technology can enhance our understanding of natural phenomena.
Sure! Here’s a sanitized version of the transcript, removing any unnecessary or repetitive phrases while maintaining the core content:
—
[Host] Thank you to Brilliant for supporting PBS. A caterpillar and a kangaroo, a stingray and a seagull, or a penguin and an ancient armored dinosaur—these animals are very different, yet they share a common trait: they are darker on top and lighter on the bottom. This pattern is found in animals worldwide, whether they are predators or prey, and regardless of their habitat.
In the 1800s, biologists were puzzled by why so many animals across diverse environments exhibited this shading pattern. Around the turn of the 20th century, an American painter named Abbott Thayer proposed that this nearly universal pattern serves as camouflage. Thayer, with his artistic background, understood that shadows play a crucial role in creating the illusion of depth on a flat canvas. He realized that many animals’ coloration cancels out the shadows cast by their bodies in sunlight.
For example, a wolf has a dark brownish top coat that fades to tan and white underneath. When in sunlight, the wolf’s upper body is illuminated while its lighter belly is in shadow, making its coat appear more uniform. Thayer called this “obliterate shading,” believing it helped animals blend into their surroundings.
Thayer tested his idea by painting wooden birds with darker tops and lighter undersides, demonstrating how they could vanish against their natural habitats. Although he extended his theory to suggest that almost all animal coloration was for camouflage, some of his claims, like flamingos blending into the sunset, were less accurate.
Today, this effect is known as counter shading, and its role in camouflage is widely accepted. For instance, some animals that hang upside down, like certain caterpillars, exhibit reverse counter shading, which helps them blend into their environment when in their typical position.
Research shows that in brightly lit habitats, counter shading patterns are more pronounced, balancing out strong shadows. Paleontologists have even found evidence of counter shading in dinosaur fossils. However, scientists are still testing Thayer’s ideas to determine how universal this trait truly is.
While some studies indicate that counter shading helps animals avoid detection, the mechanisms behind it are not fully understood. It may reduce contrast, making animals less visible to predators. Additionally, not all animals perceive the world as humans do, so counter shading might be effective even if it doesn’t completely conceal an animal.
For aquatic animals, counter shading may serve a different purpose. Since they can be viewed from multiple angles, it helps them blend into varying backgrounds. For example, a fish’s light belly conceals it against bright water, while its dark top side blends with deeper waters.
Some sea creatures have developed counter illumination, producing light on their undersides to hide their silhouettes when viewed from below.
In conclusion, while we understand some aspects of counter shading, its functions may vary among species. For example, penguins use their coloration not only for camouflage but also to regulate their temperature by absorbing sunlight.
Both predators and prey continuously evolve visual tricks to gain advantages over one another. Counter shading has proven effective enough that it has been repeatedly produced in nature for millions of years, showcasing the remarkable interplay between art and science.
Thank you for watching! A huge thank you to everyone who supports the show on Patreon. Your support helps us create these videos. If you’re not subscribed, please consider doing so and hit the bell for notifications.
Brilliant is an online learning platform for STEM with hands-on interactive lessons. It offers courses that teach problem-solving through engaging activities. For example, their computational biology course merges computer science with biology, helping students tackle foundational problems in the field.
To learn more about Brilliant, visit brilliant.org/besmart.
—
This version maintains the essence of the original transcript while ensuring clarity and coherence.
Coloration – The natural color or pattern of an animal’s skin, fur, or feathers that helps it survive in its environment. – The bright coloration of the poison dart frog warns predators that it is toxic.
Shading – The use of different tones or colors to create depth and dimension in a drawing or painting. – The artist used shading to give the leaves a more realistic appearance in the painting.
Camouflage – A method of blending in with the environment to avoid detection by predators or prey. – The chameleon uses camouflage to hide from predators by changing its skin color to match its surroundings.
Predators – Animals that hunt and eat other animals for food. – Lions are powerful predators that often hunt in groups to catch their prey.
Animals – Living organisms that can move and consume organic material for energy. – Many animals, like birds and insects, play important roles in pollinating plants.
Counter – To act in opposition to something, often to reduce its effects. – Some animals have developed thick fur to counter the cold temperatures of their habitats.
Light – A form of energy that is visible to the human eye and is essential for photosynthesis in plants. – Plants need light to produce food through the process of photosynthesis.
Science – The systematic study of the natural world through observation and experiment. – In science class, we learned about the life cycle of butterflies and how they transform from caterpillars.
Temperature – A measure of how hot or cold something is, which can affect living organisms and their environments. – The temperature of the ocean can influence the types of marine life that thrive in different regions.
Evolution – The process by which different kinds of living organisms develop and change over time. – The evolution of the giraffe’s long neck is believed to help it reach leaves high in trees.
