Why is “The Scream” screaming? – Noah Charney

Alphabets Sounds Video

share us on:

In the lesson “Why is ‘The Scream’ Screaming?” by Noah Charney, the enduring power of Edvard Munch’s iconic painting is explored through the artist’s tumultuous life experiences and emotional struggles. Munch, influenced by personal loss and illness, sought to express raw emotions rather than realistic depictions in his art, culminating in “The Scream,” which symbolizes profound angst and has become a cultural icon. The painting’s legacy, marked by its bold expressionism and widespread recognition, reflects a universal resonance with themes of horror and anxiety.

Why is “The Scream” Screaming? – Noah Charney

Imagine a sky that seems to ripple and blend into the landscape below. Two shadowy figures walk along a path, while another figure stands out, expressing intense emotion. This is the scene in Edvard Munch’s famous painting, “The Scream,” created in 1893. But what makes this artwork so powerful and enduring?

The Life of Edvard Munch

Edvard Munch was born in 1863 in Norway, one of five children. During the 1800s, tuberculosis was a devastating disease in Europe, claiming many lives, including those of Munch’s mother and older sister. Munch himself struggled with illness, and another sister faced mental health challenges, spending much of her life in an institution. Due to frequent sickness, Munch often missed school, spending his time at home drawing and listening to his father’s stories. His father, a devout Lutheran, saw Munch’s interest in art as unconventional. Munch once said, “I inherited the seeds of madness,” feeling that “the angels of fear, sorrow, and death stood by my side since the day I was born.”

Munch’s Artistic Journey

Eventually, Munch moved to Berlin, where he joined a group of artists who wanted to break away from traditional art forms. Although he had classical training, Munch was drawn to what he called “soul painting,” focusing on raw, personal emotions rather than realistic depictions. He believed that art should capture what a person feels when they see something, rather than just the object itself.

Many of Munch’s works explored themes of personal suffering, which led some critics to view his portrayals of women as harsh. Death was a recurring theme in his art, appearing in various forms, from skeletons to self-portraits and family scenes.

The Birth of “The Scream”

Munch’s art often sparked controversy, with some critics calling him “absolutely demented,” but it also received praise. His most famous work, “The Scream,” was inspired by a moment of overwhelming emotion. In a diary entry from January 22, 1892, Munch described walking with friends along a fjord near Oslo at sunset. As he leaned against a fence, he saw the sky change dramatically, describing it as “blood and tongues of fire above the blue-black fjord and the city.” While his friends walked on, Munch felt “an infinite scream passing through nature.”

Munch revisited this scene multiple times. Initially, he painted it with a more recognizable human figure, but later transformed it into a dramatic, abstract symbol. The haunting expression on the figure’s face seems to meet the viewer’s gaze directly. In the first version, he inscribed, “Could only have been painted by a madman!” Many believe the figure is not screaming but reacting to the scream around it.

The Legacy of “The Scream”

Munch created four versions of “The Scream,” all on cardboard, with two in pastel and two in paint, and produced numerous prints and lithographs. A year after the first “Scream,” he depicted the same setting with a group of despairing faces. In late 1893, Munch showcased “The Scream” at a solo exhibit in Berlin. Its bold composition contributed to the Expressionist movement, which highlighted intense psychological states and captured the emotional landscape of World War I and beyond.

“The Scream” continued to gain fame. When it entered the public domain in the mid-1900s, new renditions and reproductions spread its influence. It appeared in popular films during the 1990s, and both painted versions were stolen and later recovered in separate heists in 1994 and 2004. Over time, it became a symbol of horror and anxiety, inspiring an emoji and even being considered by the US government for marking hazardous sites for future generations.

While its cultural impact may not always reflect Munch’s personal struggles, “The Scream” has undeniably resonated with people worldwide, capturing a universal sense of angst and emotion.

  1. How does Edvard Munch’s personal history and family background influence your understanding of “The Scream” and its emotional intensity?
  2. In what ways do you think Munch’s concept of “soul painting” challenges traditional art forms, and how does this approach resonate with you?
  3. Reflect on the recurring themes of death and personal suffering in Munch’s work. How do these themes contribute to the power and impact of “The Scream”?
  4. Consider Munch’s description of the moment that inspired “The Scream.” How does this context alter your perception of the painting and its central figure?
  5. What are your thoughts on the idea that the figure in “The Scream” is reacting to the scream around it, rather than screaming itself?
  6. How do you interpret the legacy of “The Scream” in modern culture, and what does its widespread influence suggest about the universality of its themes?
  7. Discuss the significance of “The Scream” being used as a symbol of horror and anxiety in contemporary media. How does this align or conflict with Munch’s original intentions?
  8. Reflect on the impact of “The Scream” being part of the Expressionist movement. How does this movement’s focus on psychological states enhance your appreciation of the artwork?
  1. Research and Presentation on Edvard Munch’s Life

    Research the life of Edvard Munch, focusing on how his personal experiences influenced his art. Create a presentation that highlights key events in his life and how they are reflected in his works. Share your findings with the class, emphasizing the connection between Munch’s life and his artistic themes.

  2. Art Analysis: “The Scream”

    Analyze “The Scream” by examining its elements such as color, composition, and emotion. Write a short essay discussing how these elements contribute to the painting’s impact. Consider why the painting has remained powerful and relevant over time. Share your analysis with your classmates for feedback and discussion.

  3. Create Your Own “Soul Painting”

    Inspired by Munch’s concept of “soul painting,” create your own artwork that expresses a personal emotion or experience. Use any medium you prefer, such as painting, drawing, or digital art. Present your artwork to the class and explain the emotion or experience you aimed to capture and the artistic choices you made.

  4. Debate: The Impact of “The Scream” on Modern Culture

    Participate in a class debate on the cultural impact of “The Scream.” One side will argue that the painting’s influence is primarily due to its artistic merit, while the other side will argue that its impact is more about its cultural symbolism. Prepare your arguments and engage in a respectful debate, considering both historical and contemporary perspectives.

  5. Creative Writing: A Day in the Life of the Figure in “The Scream”

    Write a short story from the perspective of the figure in “The Scream.” Imagine a day in their life, exploring what might have led to the moment captured in the painting. Consider the emotions and thoughts of the figure, and how they perceive the world around them. Share your story with the class and discuss the different interpretations of the figure’s experience.

Here’s a sanitized version of the provided YouTube transcript:

An undulating sky melds into the landscape, where two silhouettes move along a balustraded walkway, and a figure’s features express deep emotion. Since Norwegian artist Edvard Munch created “The Scream” in 1893, it has become one of the world’s most famous artworks. But why has its cry resonated so profoundly and endured so long?

Munch was born in 1863, one of five children. Tuberculosis devastated Europe throughout the 1800s, claiming the lives of many, including Munch’s mother and elder sister. Soon after, Munch himself battled the disease. Another sister faced mental health challenges and spent much of her life in an institution. Meanwhile, Munch frequently missed school due to illness, often spending time at home drawing and listening to the stories his father read aloud. A devout Lutheran, his father viewed Munch’s artistic aspirations as unconventional. Munch reflected, “I inherited the seeds of madness,” stating that “the angels of fear, sorrow, and death stood by my side since the day I was born.”

Eventually, Munch moved to Berlin, where he engaged with creative circles focused on breaking away from academic traditions and developing their crafts organically. Although he had classical training, he began to immerse himself in what he termed “soul painting”—works that valued raw, subjective emotion over realistic representation. He believed, “It’s not the chair that should be painted, but what a person has felt at the sight of it.”

Many of Munch’s works explored personal suffering, which some critics interpreted as unkind portrayals of women, depicting them as cruel figures. Death often permeated Munch’s art, from skeletons to self-portraits and poignant moments with family.

Munch’s art sparked controversy—some critics labeled him as “absolutely demented”—but it also garnered acclaim. His most famous work was on the horizon. “The Scream” was inspired by a moment that overwhelmed Munch with a profound sense of anguish. In a diary entry dated January 22, 1892, Munch described walking with two friends along a fjord overlooking what is now Oslo at sunset. Leaning against a fence, he witnessed a dramatic change in the sky, describing it as “blood and tongues of fire above the blue-black fjord and the city.” As his friends continued on, Munch felt “an infinite scream passing through nature.”

Munch revisited this scene multiple times. Initially, he depicted it with a more recognizable human subject, but the following year, he transformed it into a dramatic, abstracted symbol, with the haunting expression on the figure’s face meeting the viewer’s gaze directly. In this first version, he added a subtle inscription: “Could only have been painted by a madman!” Many believe the figure is not emitting the scream but reacting to it.

Munch eventually created four versions of “The Scream”—all on cardboard, with two in pastel and two in paint—and produced numerous prints and lithographs. The year after the first “Scream,” he illustrated the same setting but with a collection of despairing faces. In late 1893, Munch premiered “The Scream” at a solo exhibit in Berlin. The artwork’s bold composition contributed to the Expressionist movement, which emphasized stark psychological states and mapped the emotional landscape of World War I and beyond.

“The Scream” continued to gain recognition. When it entered the public domain in the mid-1900s, new renditions and reproductions furthered its fame. It appeared in popular films during the 1990s, and both painted versions were stolen and later recovered in separate heists in 1994 and 2004. Over time, it became an archetypal symbol of horror and angst, inspiring an emoji and even consideration by the US government for marking hazardous sites for future generations.

While its various cultural influences may not always reflect the personal struggles Munch initially depicted, “The Scream” has undoubtedly found a near-universal resonance.

This version maintains the essence of the original transcript while removing sensitive or potentially distressing content.

ArtThe expression or application of human creative skill and imagination, typically in a visual form such as painting or sculpture, producing works to be appreciated primarily for their beauty or emotional power. – The Renaissance period was a golden age of art, where artists like Leonardo da Vinci and Michelangelo created masterpieces that continue to inspire awe.

HistoryThe study of past events, particularly in human affairs, often involving the analysis of cause and effect and the interpretation of evidence. – Understanding the history of ancient civilizations helps us appreciate the cultural and technological advancements that have shaped the modern world.

EmotionA natural instinctive state of mind deriving from one’s circumstances, mood, or relationships with others, often reflected in art to convey deeper meanings. – Vincent van Gogh’s paintings are renowned for their vibrant colors and emotional intensity, capturing the artist’s turbulent inner world.

SufferingThe state of undergoing pain, distress, or hardship, often depicted in art to evoke empathy and reflection on the human condition. – The painting “The Scream” by Edvard Munch is a powerful representation of human suffering and existential angst.

ExpressionismAn art movement that emphasizes the representation of emotional experience rather than physical reality, often through bold colors and dynamic compositions. – Expressionism emerged in the early 20th century as artists sought to convey the emotional turmoil of the modern world through their work.

LegacySomething transmitted by or received from an ancestor or predecessor, often referring to the lasting impact of an artist or historical figure. – The legacy of Pablo Picasso’s innovative techniques continues to influence contemporary artists around the globe.

PaintingThe practice of applying pigment to a surface, such as canvas, to create an image, often considered one of the most traditional forms of artistic expression. – The painting “Starry Night” by Vincent van Gogh is celebrated for its swirling, dreamlike depiction of the night sky.

LandscapeA genre of art that depicts natural scenery such as mountains, valleys, trees, rivers, and forests, often capturing the beauty and majesty of the natural world. – The landscape paintings of the Hudson River School artists highlight the sublime beauty of the American wilderness.

CultureThe arts and other manifestations of human intellectual achievement regarded collectively, often reflecting the values and beliefs of a society. – The culture of ancient Greece is renowned for its contributions to art, philosophy, and democracy, which continue to influence Western civilization.

MadnessA state of severe mental illness or irrationality, often explored in art to challenge perceptions of reality and sanity. – The theme of madness is prevalent in Francisco Goya’s later works, reflecting his disillusionment with society and the human psyche.

All Video Lessons

Login your account

Please login your account to get started.

Don't have an account?

Register your account

Please sign up your account to get started.

Already have an account?