Why Some Days Aren’t 24 Hours

Alphabets Sounds Video

share us on:

In the lesson “Understanding Days: A Journey Through Time,” students explore the concept of a “day” from different perspectives, including stellar and solar days, and how these relate to Earth’s rotation and orbit around the sun. The lesson emphasizes that while a day is commonly understood as a 24-hour period, this definition is a human invention based on precise atomic measurements rather than natural celestial cycles. By the end, students gain a deeper understanding of how timekeeping varies across different contexts, preparing them to communicate effectively with extraterrestrial beings.

Understanding Days: A Journey Through Time

Imagine a future where aliens living on asteroids near the center of the galaxy want to visit you. Excitedly, you tell them, “Sure! I’m free any day this week.” But there’s a problem—they don’t understand what a “day” means because their calendar is completely different. To them, the idea of a “day” is very alien.

Explaining a Day: The Stellar Day

You start by explaining that a day is the time it takes for Earth to complete a full rotation on its axis. The aliens input this into their computer simulation, but you quickly realize there’s a flaw. As Earth rotates, it also moves around the sun. By the time Earth reaches the other side of the sun, our “daytime” and “nighttime” have switched places! This isn’t what we mean by a calendar day. What you’ve described is a “Stellar day,” which is measured with respect to a distant, stationary point in space. However, our concept of a day is more about the sun, not the galaxy.

Trying Again: The Solar Day

You give it another shot. This time, you explain that a day is the time it takes for the sun to return to its highest point in the sky. The aliens adjust their instruments, but their day counter doesn’t match your clock. It’s starting the new day earlier and earlier, then later and later. This isn’t a mistake in their programming—it’s a feature of Earth’s orbit. What you’ve described is a “Solar day,” which isn’t the same as a day kept by a clock. The length of time between when the sun is highest changes throughout the year because of Earth’s elliptical orbit and tilted axis.

The Standard Day: A Fixed Time Period

If we used solar days in everyday life, our calendars and clocks would have to change the number of minutes and seconds in a day depending on the time of year. Sundials naturally do this, but they have other drawbacks. Changing the length of a second or the number of seconds in an hour isn’t practical for regular or interplanetary use.

So, you tell the aliens that a day is an invented time period that is 24 hours long. Each hour is defined by 33 trillion oscillations of a special kind of photon emitted by a cesium atom. If they want to know why a day is defined this way and how it relates to Earth’s rotation, you can direct them to an interactive video on MinuteLabs. This video explains solar, stellar, and standard 24-hour days, how they’re related, and how Earth’s orbit affects them. It even lets you experiment with different orbits to see how they change the length of days!

With this knowledge, you’ll be ready to coordinate a visit with aliens, no matter what day it may be.

  1. How did the article change your understanding of what constitutes a “day”? What new insights did you gain about the different types of days?
  2. Reflect on the challenges of explaining Earth concepts, like a “day,” to beings with different experiences. How might this apply to communicating complex ideas in your own life?
  3. Consider the differences between a stellar day and a solar day. How do these differences impact our daily lives, even if we aren’t consciously aware of them?
  4. What are the implications of defining a day as a fixed 24-hour period, despite the natural variations in solar days? How does this standardization affect our perception of time?
  5. In what ways does the article highlight the importance of perspective when understanding time and space? How can this perspective be applied to other areas of knowledge?
  6. How might the concept of a “day” differ for inhabitants of other planets or celestial bodies? What factors would influence their understanding of time?
  7. Discuss the role of technology, such as the cesium atom’s oscillations, in defining and measuring time. How does this reliance on technology shape our daily lives?
  8. After reading the article, how would you explain the concept of a “day” to someone unfamiliar with Earth’s timekeeping systems? What key points would you emphasize?
  1. Create a Model of Earth’s Rotation

    Using a globe or a ball, simulate Earth’s rotation and orbit around the sun. Mark a point on the globe to represent your location. Rotate the globe to show how a “Stellar day” differs from a “Solar day.” Discuss with your classmates how Earth’s tilt and orbit affect the length of a day.

  2. Interactive Video Exploration

    Watch the interactive video on MinuteLabs about solar, stellar, and standard 24-hour days. Experiment with different orbits in the simulation to see how they change the length of days. Share your findings with the class and discuss how this knowledge could help coordinate activities with the aliens.

  3. Design a Sundial

    Work in groups to design and build a simple sundial. Use it to track the sun’s position throughout the day. Compare the time shown on your sundial with a standard clock and discuss any differences you observe. Reflect on how ancient civilizations might have used sundials to measure time.

  4. Time Zone Investigation

    Research how time zones work and why they are necessary. Create a presentation explaining how time zones are related to Earth’s rotation and the concept of a 24-hour day. Consider how time zones would be important for coordinating a visit with the aliens.

  5. Cesium Atom Experiment

    Learn about how cesium atoms are used to define a second. Conduct a simple experiment or demonstration that illustrates the concept of atomic timekeeping. Discuss why this method is more reliable than using solar or stellar days for keeping time.

DayThe period of time it takes for the Earth to complete one full rotation on its axis, typically 24 hours. – The length of a day on Earth is about 24 hours, which is the time it takes for the planet to spin once on its axis.

EarthThe third planet from the Sun in our solar system, which is home to all known life. – Earth is the only planet in our solar system that has liquid water on its surface, making it unique for supporting life.

SunThe star at the center of our solar system that provides light and heat to the planets orbiting it. – The Sun is a massive ball of gas that emits light and heat, which are essential for life on Earth.

SolarRelating to or determined by the Sun. – Solar energy is harnessed from the Sun’s rays and can be used to generate electricity.

StellarRelating to stars or celestial objects. – The stellar explosion known as a supernova can outshine an entire galaxy for a short period.

OrbitThe curved path of an object around a star, planet, or moon, especially a periodic elliptical revolution. – Earth orbits the Sun in an elliptical path, taking about 365.25 days to complete one revolution.

AxisAn imaginary line about which a body rotates. – Earth’s axis is tilted at an angle of about 23.5 degrees, which is why we experience different seasons.

TimeA measured or measurable period during which an action, process, or condition exists or continues. – In physics, time is a fundamental quantity used to sequence events and compare the durations of events and the intervals between them.

PhotonA particle representing a quantum of light or other electromagnetic radiation. – Photons are the basic units of light and are responsible for transmitting electromagnetic energy.

CalendarA system for organizing and dividing time, typically based on the cycles of the moon or the Sun. – The Gregorian calendar, which is widely used today, is based on the Earth’s orbit around the Sun.

All Video Lessons

Login your account

Please login your account to get started.

Don't have an account?

Register your account

Please sign up your account to get started.

Already have an account?