Back in 2013, SpaceX embarked on a groundbreaking mission: to land their Falcon 9 rocket back on Earth. The challenge was immense, as they aimed to land on a floating droneship in the ocean, a feat that seemed nearly impossible at the time. However, achieving this would mark a significant leap in making rockets reusable.
SpaceX began testing various vehicles to master rocket landings. After years of trials and errors, they succeeded. Today, the sight of a Falcon 9 landing is almost routine. This success has not only demonstrated engineering prowess but also saved SpaceX over $1.4 billion in the last five years by reusing boosters instead of building new ones. Currently, SpaceX stands as the only company to have successfully landed and reused an orbital rocket booster.
SpaceX is now focused on Starship, a new chapter in their space exploration journey. The Starship program has already showcased impressive test flights, such as the SN8 flight, proving the viability of their plans. In a surprising twist, Elon Musk announced an ambitious plan to catch the Super Heavy booster mid-air as it returns to the launch site.
While this idea might sound far-fetched, SpaceX isn’t alone in exploring such concepts. Rocket Lab plans to catch their Electron rocket using parachutes and a helicopter. Even NASA, back in the 1960s, considered catching the Saturn V first stage with a helicopter. Compared to these, SpaceX’s plan seems relatively feasible.
To grasp why SpaceX is pursuing this bold idea, we need to understand Starship’s ultimate goal. Starship consists of two stages: the Super Heavy booster and the Starship itself. The booster lifts Starship out of the atmosphere, and then Starship continues to orbit. After separation, Super Heavy returns to Earth, similar to Falcon 9.
The vision for Starship includes missions to the Moon and Mars, as well as Earth-to-Earth travel, requiring frequent flights with quick turnaround times. Initially, SpaceX planned for Super Heavy to land directly on the launch mount, but this required precision beyond current capabilities. Instead, they opted for landing on a pad and using a crane to reposition it, which would require large landing legs for shock absorption.
Falcon 9 boosters need to be transported for inspection and refurbishment, a time-consuming process. A significant part of this involves the landing legs. By eliminating the legs, SpaceX can simplify turnaround times and reduce weight, allowing for heavier payloads. Without legs, catching the booster becomes the only viable option, albeit requiring precise execution.
Super Heavy has an advantage over Falcon 9: it can hover. This capability allows it to adjust its course before landing. SpaceX plans to catch the booster using a giant arm on the launch tower. As Super Heavy approaches, it will align with the catching arms, which will lock into place.
The catcher will hook onto the grid fins, which are designed to withstand the forces of reentry. This method will still require shock absorption, integrated into the catcher rather than the rocket, reducing stress and refurbishment needs.
The main advantage of this approach is the potential for rapid relaunch. If Super Heavy can be immediately placed back on the launch mount, it can be prepared for its next flight quickly. This is crucial for Starship, as it will contain excess methane after landing, which needs to be reused rather than vented.
While it may take a few years for SpaceX to attempt this ambitious plan, it’s exciting to see them tackle these engineering challenges. SpaceX’s first booster landing reshaped our understanding of spaceflight, and their current endeavors continue to push the boundaries of what’s possible.
If you’re interested in supporting Primal Space, consider becoming a Patron for exclusive content and community access. Thank you for engaging with this journey, and we look forward to sharing more exciting developments with you.
Research and present a timeline of SpaceX’s journey from the initial Falcon 9 landings to the current Starship program. Highlight key milestones and technological advancements. Discuss how these developments have impacted the aerospace industry.
In groups, brainstorm and design a conceptual model of a catching mechanism for the Super Heavy booster. Consider the engineering challenges and propose solutions. Present your design to the class, explaining the rationale behind your choices.
Engage in a structured debate on the feasibility of SpaceX’s plan to catch the Super Heavy booster mid-air. Divide into teams to argue for and against the concept, using evidence from the article and additional research to support your points.
Use a physics simulation software to model the landing of a rocket booster. Experiment with different variables such as landing speed, angle, and environmental conditions. Analyze the results and discuss how these factors influence the success of a landing.
Conduct a cost-benefit analysis of reusable rockets versus expendable rockets. Consider factors such as manufacturing costs, refurbishment, and turnaround times. Present your findings in a report, highlighting the economic implications for space exploration companies.
In 2013, SpaceX announced plans to attempt landing their Falcon 9 rocket back on Earth. To add to the complexity, they aimed to land on a floating droneship in the middle of the ocean. This was an unprecedented challenge, and at the time, it seemed like an impossible goal. However, if successful, it would represent a significant advancement in rocket reusability. SpaceX began experimenting with various test vehicles to learn how to land a rocket. After several years and numerous setbacks, SpaceX achieved this remarkable feat. Five years after that historic first landing, the sight of a Falcon 9 landing has become routine. With the frequency of launches, SpaceX has perfected this engineering achievement and saved a substantial amount of money. Each time a Falcon 9 is reused, they save on the cost of building a new booster. In the last five years alone, this has saved SpaceX over $1.4 billion. To date, SpaceX remains the only company that has successfully landed and reused an orbital rocket booster.
Now, SpaceX is focusing on Starship, the next evolution of their ambitious space endeavors. Those following the Starship program have witnessed some incredible test flights, including the recent SN8 flight, which showcased the feasibility of their plans for Starship. Just when it seemed that SpaceX’s innovations couldn’t get any more ambitious, Elon Musk announced a new plan to catch the Super Heavy booster mid-air as it approaches the launch mount.
While this may sound like another outlandish idea from Elon, SpaceX is not the only company considering catching rockets from the sky. Rocket Lab plans to catch their Electron rocket using parachutes and a helicopter. In the 1960s, NASA even contemplated catching the massive Saturn V first stage with a helicopter featuring rotor blades over 100 meters long. Compared to these ideas, SpaceX’s plan seems somewhat less radical.
Before delving into the details of how and why SpaceX is pursuing this ambitious concept, we want to acknowledge our sponsor, Private Internet Access. Many people are still unaware of how a VPN can enhance their internet experience. Private Internet Access is a leading no-log VPN service with access to over 10,000 servers in more than 70 countries. Whether you’re using a computer, tablet, or smartphone, Private Internet Access has you covered. If you want to unblock streaming services like Netflix, Amazon Prime, and Disney Plus, this VPN can help. Their secure servers protect your data from spammers and hackers, which is increasingly important as more people work from home. To support Primal Space and secure your data, visit privateinternetaccess.com/primalspace for two years of complete access for just $2.59 a month, plus an extra three months free. With multiple payment options and a 30-day money-back guarantee, you have nothing to lose. Protect your internet data today with Private Internet Access.
Now, back to SpaceX’s plan to catch the Super Heavy booster. To understand the reasoning behind this, we need to look at the overall goal of Starship. Starship consists of two stages: the booster stage called Super Heavy and the second stage simply called Starship. Super Heavy lifts the second stage out of the thickest parts of the atmosphere, while Starship completes the journey to orbit. After separation, Super Heavy returns to land, similar to the Falcon 9.
The goal for Starship is to travel to the Moon and Mars. To achieve this, SpaceX plans to use a fleet of Starships for in-space refueling. Additionally, they aim to utilize Starship for Earth-to-Earth passenger travel, necessitating multiple flights per day with turnaround times comparable to commercial airliners. The original plan for Super Heavy was to land directly on the launch mount, making it ready for its next flight. However, this would require a level of precision beyond what SpaceX has demonstrated with Falcon 9 landings. Consequently, they shifted to the idea of landing Super Heavy on a landing pad and using a giant crane to lift it onto the launch mount. This would necessitate at least six large landing legs with sufficient shock absorption to handle the landing.
However, the Falcon 9 landings require transporting the booster back to a refurbishment hangar for inspection and component replacement, which is time-consuming. One critical aspect of this process is the landing legs. Removing the legs from the design would simplify the turnaround time and save a significant amount of weight. Every kilogram saved allows the rocket to carry heavier payloads into orbit. With six legs, the landing gear would constitute around 10% of the entire booster’s mass upon landing. Without legs, SpaceX’s only option is to catch the booster, which still requires a high degree of precision.
One advantage Super Heavy has over Falcon 9 is its ability to hover. While Falcon 9 must perform a “suicide burn” to land, Super Heavy can reduce its thrust-to-weight ratio to allow for hovering. This gives it extra time to adjust its course before landing. SpaceX plans to catch the booster using a giant arm attached to the launch tower. As Super Heavy approaches, it will align with the catching arms, which will retract and lock into place.
The catcher will hook onto the grid fins, which are designed to handle significant drag during reentry, making them strong enough to bear the load of the booster. Although this method of landing is unique, it will still require shock absorption to manage the final energy and bring the booster to a stop. Normally, shock absorption is handled by the landing legs on Falcon 9, which consist of telescopic tubes filled with compressed helium. As the legs fold, the gas acts as a shock absorber. In this case, the shock absorption will be integrated into the catcher rather than the rocket, reducing stress on the rocket and minimizing the need for major refurbishment.
SpaceX may use a similar air suspension system on a larger scale or consider a cable-catching system akin to those used on aircraft carriers. This system employs multiple steel ropes designed to be caught by an aircraft’s tailhook, with energy absorbed by hydraulic damping systems. Transferring this system to the landing arm will allow Super Heavy to remain as lightweight as possible while minimizing stress on the rocket.
The real advantage of this approach is the potential for rapid relaunch. If Super Heavy can be lowered onto the launch mount immediately after landing, it can be secured, detanked, and inspected for its next flight. This is particularly important for Starship, as it will still contain excess methane after landing, which cannot be vented into the atmosphere. SpaceX plans to pump the leftover methane back into the tank farm for reuse.
While we may have to wait a few more years for SpaceX to attempt this ambitious idea, it is inspiring to see them tackle these engineering challenges. When SpaceX landed their first booster five years ago, it reshaped our understanding of what is possible and significantly advanced the field of spaceflight. Regardless of the outcome, it is evident that we are witnessing history in the making.
If you would like to support Primal Space, consider becoming a Patron for input on videos and exclusive access to our Discord server. Thank you for watching, and we’ll see you in the next video.
Rocket – A vehicle or device propelled by the rapid expulsion of gases, used for travel or transport in space. – The engineering team spent months designing a rocket capable of reaching Mars.
Engineering – The application of scientific and mathematical principles to design and build structures, machines, and systems. – Engineering students often work on projects that involve creating sustainable energy solutions.
Booster – A component of a rocket that provides additional thrust to help propel it into space. – The booster separated from the main rocket after reaching the upper atmosphere.
Spaceflight – The act of traveling into or through outer space. – Advances in technology have made spaceflight more accessible to private companies.
Landing – The process of bringing a spacecraft safely back to the surface of a celestial body. – The successful landing of the rover on Mars marked a significant achievement in space exploration.
Payloads – The cargo or instruments carried by a spacecraft, which can include satellites, scientific equipment, or crew. – The rocket was designed to carry multiple payloads into orbit, including a weather satellite and a research module.
Atmosphere – The layer of gases surrounding a planet, which can affect the design and operation of spacecraft. – Engineers must consider the atmosphere’s density when designing heat shields for re-entry vehicles.
Missions – Planned operations or journeys undertaken by spacecraft to achieve specific objectives in space exploration. – The upcoming missions to the moon aim to establish a permanent lunar base.
Refurbishment – The process of renovating and updating equipment or structures to extend their usability and efficiency. – The refurbishment of the space station’s solar panels increased its energy capacity significantly.
Methane – A colorless, odorless gas used as a fuel in rocket propulsion systems due to its efficiency and availability. – The new rocket engines are designed to use methane as a propellant, reducing overall emissions.
