Have you ever tried using WiFi on a flight and felt instant regret? After going through the hassle of entering your payment details and logging in, you often find yourself with an internet connection that feels like it’s from a bygone era. Airplane WiFi isn’t a new concept; it dates back to 2001 when Boeing introduced a service called Connexion. Although it was slow and expensive, the lack of streaming platforms like YouTube and Netflix at the time meant that people didn’t need high-speed internet.
To understand why airplane WiFi is often slow, we need to look at how it works. Airplanes can connect to the internet in two ways: through cell towers on the ground or via satellites. Most flights over land use the air-to-ground method, connecting to cell towers similar to the 4G ones our phones use. However, because planes fly at high altitudes, the signal strength is limited to about 3 megabits per second, compared to the 40 megabits per second you might get from a 4G tower. This limited bandwidth is shared among all passengers, which is why airplane WiFi is often sluggish. Airlines charge high prices for WiFi to limit the number of users, ensuring better speeds for those who pay.
SpaceX offers a promising alternative with satellite internet. Traditionally, a ground-based antenna sends signals to a geostationary satellite 36,000 km above Earth, which then relays the signal to the airplane. These satellites use Ku or Ka band systems, achieving speeds of up to 50 or 70 megabits per second. While this is faster than cell towers, the limited number of satellites means many planes and users share the same satellite, slowing down the connection.
Starlink, SpaceX’s satellite internet service, could revolutionize in-flight WiFi. When a satellite sends a signal to Earth, the signal weakens with distance. Geostationary satellites are much further away than Starlink satellites, which are much closer to Earth. This proximity reduces signal loss and allows Starlink to use less powerful transmitters and antennas. Starlink’s satellites are 65 times closer to Earth, resulting in lower latency, which is the delay before data begins to transfer. Although this delay is measured in milliseconds, it significantly affects how quickly web pages load, as devices download data in small chunks. Lower latency means more data can be sent each second, enhancing the browsing experience.
Starlink’s network of thousands of satellites allows for better distribution of demand, meaning airplanes won’t have to share bandwidth with as many other users. This should significantly increase the bandwidth available to each plane. Additionally, Starlink’s phased array antennas, which steer signals without moving parts, reduce drag on airplanes, saving fuel and costs for airlines.
Beyond passenger internet access, Starlink could enable airplanes to send real-time data back to airlines. This could be crucial in understanding incidents like the disappearance of Malaysian Airlines flight 370. Currently, airplanes record flight data on a device in the tail, which is only useful if the plane is found. With increased bandwidth from Starlink, planes could transmit data and video feeds in real time, aiding in crash investigations.
While there are still regulatory and cost challenges to overcome, SpaceX has already signed agreements to provide WiFi for Hawaiian Airlines and JSX Airlines. In the future, we might be able to stream videos and play games while flying at high speeds.
If you’re interested in learning more about space and technology, CuriosityStream offers a wealth of documentaries on topics like the Apollo Moon landings and the history of spaceflight. It’s a streaming service similar to Netflix but focused on science, nature, history, and technology. You can access it on any device, and it offers thousands of award-winning documentaries.
For more information, visit CuriosityStream to get a year’s subscription for just $14.99. Additionally, consider supporting educational content creators by becoming a Patron, where you can contribute to video content and join exclusive communities.
Research the history and evolution of airplane WiFi from its inception to the present day. Prepare a presentation that highlights key technological advancements and challenges faced over the years. Focus on how these developments have shaped the current state of in-flight connectivity.
Participate in a debate where you argue for or against the use of satellite internet versus air-to-ground internet for in-flight WiFi. Consider factors such as speed, cost, reliability, and future potential. This will help you understand the pros and cons of each method.
Analyze a case study on how Starlink’s satellite internet could impact airlines and passengers. Discuss the potential benefits and drawbacks, including cost implications, user experience, and operational efficiency. Present your findings in a written report.
Join an interactive workshop where you design a satellite network for optimal in-flight WiFi coverage. Use simulation tools to understand how satellite positioning and bandwidth allocation affect internet performance. This hands-on activity will deepen your understanding of network design.
Engage in a brainstorming session to explore future prospects of in-flight WiFi technology. Consider emerging technologies, regulatory challenges, and potential new services. Share your ideas in a group discussion and create a vision board for the future of in-flight connectivity.
Here’s a sanitized version of the YouTube transcript:
—
This video is supported by CuriosityStream. If you’ve ever been on a flight and purchased the onboard WiFi, you’ll know that this experience is often followed by instant regret. After entering your card details and dealing with a frustrating login page, you’re faced with an internet connection that feels outdated. Airplane WiFi isn’t a new concept; back in 2001, Boeing introduced their own WiFi service called Connection, spelled with an X, reflecting the early 2000s. This service was slow and costly, but without platforms like YouTube and Netflix, people didn’t require such fast internet.
So, why is airplane WiFi so slow, and how is SpaceX poised to improve it? To answer this, we need to explore how airplane WiFi currently operates. An airplane has two methods for sending and receiving signals: via cell towers on the ground or through satellites. Since most flights occur over land, airlines typically prefer the air-to-ground method. These cell towers are similar to the 4G ones our phones connect to. However, because an airplane is much higher up, the signal maxes out at around 3 megabits per second, compared to the 40 megabits per second you would get from a 4G tower. With such limited bandwidth shared among multiple passengers, it’s no surprise that airplane WiFi is often slow. Consequently, airlines can charge significantly for their WiFi to limit the number of users, ensuring that the few who do pay for it experience better speeds.
A faster alternative comes from above, and this is where SpaceX enters the picture. For satellite internet, a ground-based antenna transmits the signal to a geostationary satellite 36,000 km above the Earth. The satellite then relays that signal down to the airplane, where it’s received by a large antenna on top of the fuselage. These satellites typically use Ku or Ka band systems to communicate, achieving speeds of up to 50 or 70 megabits per second. While this is an improvement over cell towers, the limited number of satellites means multiple planes and users connect to the same satellite, resulting in slower speeds.
So, how could Starlink address this issue and provide much more bandwidth to an airplane? When a satellite sends its signal to Earth, the power of that signal decreases with distance. For example, if your satellite is 100 meters away and you receive a signal power of 100, doubling the distance would reduce the power to 25. The lower the power, the more it blends in with surrounding noise, causing parts of the signal to be lost. As the distance increases, bandwidth hits a limit, and data speeds drop. This is similar to the signal you receive from your home WiFi router if you move it several streets away. Since geostationary satellites are much further away than Starlink satellites, the effect is significant. To compensate for this power deficit, geostationary satellites must use much more powerful transmitters and antennas, which can only be so powerful. To match the power received from a Starlink satellite, a geostationary satellite’s antenna and transmitter would need to be enormous, making them too large to fit into a rocket’s fairing.
Starlink’s biggest advantage may lie in its extremely low latency. Starlink satellites are 65 times closer to Earth than geostationary satellites, resulting in significantly shorter signal travel times. Although we’re only talking milliseconds, this latency greatly impacts loading webpages, as devices need to download multiple elements like images, text, and advertisements. This data isn’t downloaded all at once; instead, devices obtain it in small windows of information. For instance, if the window is 1,000 kb and you are 100 ms away from the satellite, the sender transmits the first 1,000 kb of data to your device, which it receives in 100 ms. Your device then sends an acknowledgment that it received the data, taking another 100 ms. The sender can then continue transmitting the next window of data, and this process repeats. These small gaps between transmissions accumulate over time. Lowering latency significantly increases how much data can be sent each second. With a geostationary satellite, the signal takes at least 250 ms to reach its destination, while with Starlink, the realistic latency is much closer to just 20 ms.
Ultimately, this speed would be ineffective if the bandwidth were still shared among many users. However, since Starlink has thousands of satellites operating just above the Earth’s surface, the demand can be distributed, and airplanes won’t have to share bandwidth with as many other customers. As a result, the amount of bandwidth available to a single plane should increase significantly. But the actual speed of the WiFi isn’t the only reason Starlink is appealing to airlines.
The antennas on most airliners are large and bulky, as they need to physically move to track satellites. This protrusion on the airplane’s fuselage creates drag, increasing fuel consumption by 0.3%. While this may seem minor, over time, it can cost airlines millions of dollars. The advantage of Starlink is that it uses a phased array antenna, allowing the signal to be directed without any moving parts. It employs destructive and constructive interference to steer radio waves in the right direction. This method is not only more precise but also takes up less space, as seen with the Starlink antenna on the side of Starship. SpaceX used Starlink during a test flight to send vehicle data back to engineers.
But what if airplanes could also utilize Starlink for this purpose? Malaysian Airlines flight 370 is just one of many airplanes that have gone missing in recent decades. Typically, airplanes record vast amounts of flight data onto a recorder located in the tail of the aircraft. After a crash, this recorder helps investigators understand what went wrong. However, if the plane cannot be found, there’s little information to glean from the crash. Airplanes have gradually begun sending more data back to manufacturers during flights, but the amount they can send remains limited. If Starlink could provide a significant bandwidth increase, each airplane could start sending streams of vehicle data and video feeds back to the airline in real time. This could be a crucial tool in determining what went wrong during a crash.
Although there are still many cost hurdles and strict regulations to navigate, SpaceX has already signed a deal to begin providing WiFi for Hawaiian Airlines and JSX Airlines next year. So, perhaps one day in the future, we will be able to effortlessly stream videos and play games while flying at 900 km/h.
Speaking of streaming, CuriosityStream is a streaming service similar to Netflix but designed for those interested in science, nature, history, and technology. This month, I highly recommend a show on the Apollo Moon landings, which explores everything we love about spaceflight’s most incredible achievement. It also features Laika the dog, the first animal to orbit the Earth. If that isn’t a compelling reason to watch, I don’t know what is! CuriosityStream is available on any device at any time and features thousands of award-winning exclusive documentaries that would be perfect for you. To check out CuriosityStream, go to curiositystream.com/primalspace to get an entire year’s worth of access for just $14.99. That’s just over one dollar per month.
If you’d like to support the channel even more, consider becoming a Patron, where you can provide input on each video and gain exclusive access to our Discord server. Thank you for watching, and I’ll see you in the next video.
—
This version maintains the original content while removing any informal language and ensuring a more polished presentation.
Wifi – A technology that allows electronic devices to connect to a wireless local area network (WLAN), typically using radio waves. – University campuses often provide free wifi to ensure students can access online resources anywhere on the premises.
Satellites – Artificial objects placed into orbit around celestial bodies to collect data or enable communication. – Satellites play a crucial role in modern communication systems, enabling global internet access and real-time data transmission.
Bandwidth – The maximum rate of data transfer across a given path, often measured in bits per second. – High bandwidth is essential for streaming high-definition video content without buffering.
Latency – The delay before a transfer of data begins following an instruction for its transfer. – In online gaming, low latency is crucial to ensure smooth and responsive gameplay.
Data – Information processed or stored by a computer, which can be in the form of text, images, audio, or video. – Researchers analyze large sets of data to identify patterns and make predictions in various scientific fields.
Signal – An electrical impulse or radio wave transmitted or received, conveying information. – Engineers work to improve signal strength to enhance the quality of wireless communications.
Technology – The application of scientific knowledge for practical purposes, especially in industry. – Advances in technology have revolutionized the way we communicate, making it faster and more efficient.
Airplanes – Powered flying vehicles with fixed wings and a weight greater than that of the air they displace, used for transporting passengers and goods. – The development of airplanes has significantly reduced travel time between continents, facilitating global connectivity.
Space – The physical universe beyond the earth’s atmosphere, where celestial bodies and phenomena exist. – The exploration of space has led to numerous technological advancements and a better understanding of our universe.
Efficiency – The ratio of useful output to total input in any system, often used to measure the performance of machines or processes. – Improving the efficiency of solar panels is a key focus in renewable energy research to maximize energy output from sunlight.
