In the intriguing world of medieval Europe, there were some truly bizarre events, one of which involved putting pigs on trial for murder. This peculiar practice took place in France between 1200 and 1750, where animals, particularly pigs, were sometimes treated as if they were human criminals.
Over 500 years ago, in the small French village of Savage, a tragic event unfolded. A five-year-old boy was attacked in broad daylight by a sow and her six piglets. The villagers were horrified, and in response, all seven pigs were arrested and put on trial for murder, just like human defendants.
Initially, the pigs’ owner was taken into custody, but the judge decided he was not responsible for their actions. Thus, the pigs alone faced the charges. They were kept in prison to prevent any further incidents while awaiting their trial.
The trial of the pigs mirrored that of a human court case, complete with attorneys for both the defense and prosecution. The piglets received lighter sentences due to their age and insufficient evidence of their involvement. However, since their owner refused to vouch for their future behavior, they were given to Catherine Dubarnal, the lady of Savage.
The mother sow, on the other hand, faced a damning case. With over nine witnesses testifying against her and her unruly behavior in court, she was found guilty. After nearly a month in jail, she was sentenced to death and publicly hanged from a tree, alongside other criminals.
While this story may seem extraordinary, animal trials were not uncommon in medieval and early modern France. Between the 10th and 18th centuries, over 100 such trials occurred. Animals like locusts and horses were also tried for various offenses, but pigs were most frequently charged with murder.
During the Middle Ages, pigs roamed freely in rural areas, and parents often allowed their children to play outside unsupervised. However, this was not always safe, as evidenced by the pig trials. There were instances where pigs attacked small children, sometimes with fatal consequences.
Historians have debated the reasons behind these trials. One theory suggests that they helped communities cope with tragedy by attributing it to a rational decision-maker. Another theory posits that public trials and executions served as warnings to parents about the dangers of leaving children unattended. The spectacle of pigs being paraded through the streets and executed was meant to send a strong message.
Some scholars, however, view these trials as a parody of the legal system, reflecting humans’ desire to assert control over all aspects of life. Although animal trials spread to nearby regions, they began to decline by the 18th century. The Enlightenment brought a renewed focus on Roman law, which held that animals were not rational beings and could not be tried for crimes. Over time, European legal systems evolved to resemble modern courts, where only humans could be held accountable for murder.
Reenact a mock trial where you and your classmates take on roles as judges, lawyers, and witnesses in a medieval pig trial. Use historical context to argue both for and against the pigs, considering the legal and societal norms of the time. This will help you understand the complexities and absurdities of medieval justice systems.
Engage in a debate about whether animals can be held accountable for their actions. Consider the philosophical and ethical implications of attributing rationality to animals, and discuss how these ideas have evolved from medieval times to the present day.
Conduct a research project on animal trials in different cultures and historical periods. Compare and contrast these practices with those in medieval Europe, and present your findings to the class. This will broaden your understanding of how different societies have dealt with similar issues.
Write a short story or diary entry from the perspective of one of the pigs on trial. Use historical details to create a narrative that explores the emotions and thoughts of the animal, providing insight into the human-animal relationship during medieval times.
Participate in a discussion panel that examines how legal systems have evolved from medieval times to the modern era. Focus on the role of rationality and accountability in the justice system, and how these concepts have changed over time.
This video has been made possible by Skillshare. Skillshare is an online learning community with thousands of inspiring classes for creative and curious people, where classes are broken into three major categories: Create, Build, and Thrive. If you’re a creative person and you love letting your imagination run wild, Skillshare is exactly the right place for you. With a wide variety of topics to help you do just that, we highly recommend taking a look at a new Skillshare course, “Find Your Style: 5 Exercises to Unlock Your Creative Identity” by Andy J. Pizza. This course helped us improve our creative style and broaden our artistic horizons. If you want to try this course or any of the other premium ad-free courses available on Skillshare, use the link in the description to sign up. If you’re one of the first 1,000 people to sign up using the link, you’ll get a one-month free trial of Skillshare premium membership to explore your creativity today. So click on the link in the description down below to give Skillshare a try today; you won’t regret it.
Now, let’s dive into a fascinating historical event: the trial of pigs for murder in medieval France from 1200 to 1750. Over 500 years ago, the small French village of Savage was rocked by a horrific tragedy. A five-year-old boy was playing alone in the street when a group of attackers accosted him, resulting in a shocking crime. It was broad daylight, and the bold perpetrators made no attempt to conceal their actions. However, the striking feature of this case was that the attackers were pigs, specifically a sow accompanied by her six piglets.
The villagers were understandably appalled by the event, and all seven pigs were arrested and put through a criminal trial as if they were human beings. Although the pig’s owner was initially arrested, the judge ruled that he was not liable for the pigs’ actions, leaving just the pigs to be indicted for murder. They were kept in prison while awaiting trial, as the village did not want a murderous gang on the loose.
The trial played out like a human trial, with attorneys arguing for both the defense and prosecution. The piglets received lighter sentences due to their age and lack of evidence proving they were active participants in the crime. However, because their original owner was not willing to guarantee their future good behavior, they were forfeited to Catherine Dubarnal, the lady of Savage. As for their mother, the case was clear-cut, with over nine witnesses testifying against her. Her disrespectful behavior in court, including grunting and trying to poke her nose through the bars, did not help her case. After spending nearly a month in jail, she was found guilty and sentenced to death. Within days, she was publicly hanged from a tree by her hind legs alongside other condemned criminals.
While this may seem bizarre, animal trials were relatively common in medieval and early modern France. Between the 10th and 18th centuries, over 100 animal trials took place. Sometimes, swarms of locusts were tried for trespassing and crop destruction, and other times, horses were charged with sodomy. However, it was primarily pigs that faced murder charges.
This raises some interesting questions. Firstly, why were pigs so dangerous during the Middle Ages? It was common to see pigs roaming freely in rural communities, and parents felt comfortable allowing their children to explore outside unattended. However, this did not mean it was entirely safe, as the pig trials illustrate. There were instances where small children came into contact with pigs, and sometimes those pigs had a taste for human flesh.
As for why the courts conducted formal trials for pigs, historians have differing opinions. One theory suggests that these trials helped folk communities restore order after unsettling events by framing the tragedy as the decision of a rational actor. Others speculate that public trials and executions served as warnings to parents not to leave their children unattended. Criminal pigs were paraded through the streets on their way to execution, sometimes dressed in human clothes, and their corpses were displayed to send a message.
Some scholars dismiss these theories as absurd, viewing the trials as a parody of the law and an example of humans extending their authority over all aspects of life. Animal trials spread to nearby regions, but by the 18th century, they began to decline. The Enlightenment brought a revival of Roman law, which held that animals were not rational and therefore could not be tried for crimes. Over time, European legal systems evolved to resemble modern courts, where only humans could be tried for murder.
Medieval – Relating to the Middle Ages, a period in European history from the 5th to the late 15th century, characterized by feudalism, the rise of monarchies, and the spread of Christianity. – The medieval period saw the construction of many iconic cathedrals and castles that still stand today.
Europe – A continent located entirely in the Northern Hemisphere and mostly in the Eastern Hemisphere, known for its diverse cultures, languages, and historical significance. – The Renaissance, a pivotal cultural movement, began in Europe and significantly influenced art, science, and philosophy.
Pigs – Domesticated animals that have been raised for their meat and other products, often symbolizing agricultural practices and economic structures in historical societies. – In medieval Europe, pigs were a crucial part of the rural economy, providing meat and other resources for communities.
Trial – A formal examination of evidence in a court, typically with a judge and jury, to determine guilt or innocence in historical and modern legal systems. – The trial of Socrates is one of the most famous legal proceedings in ancient history, highlighting issues of justice and morality.
Murder – The unlawful premeditated killing of one human being by another, often a subject of legal and moral discussions in historical contexts. – The murder of Julius Caesar marked a significant turning point in Roman history, leading to the end of the Roman Republic.
History – The study of past events, particularly in human affairs, encompassing a wide range of topics from ancient civilizations to modern societies. – Understanding history is crucial for analyzing how past events shape current social and political structures.
Sociology – The study of the development, structure, and functioning of human society, including the examination of social institutions, relationships, and cultures. – Sociology provides insights into how societal norms and values influence individual behavior and group dynamics.
Community – A group of people living in the same place or having a particular characteristic in common, often studied in sociology for its social dynamics and cultural significance. – The concept of community is central to understanding how individuals interact and form social bonds within societies.
Justice – The quality of being fair and reasonable, often explored in historical and sociological contexts as a fundamental principle of legal and ethical systems. – The pursuit of justice has been a driving force behind many social movements throughout history.
Enlightenment – An intellectual and philosophical movement in 18th-century Europe that emphasized reason, individualism, and skepticism of traditional doctrines. – The Enlightenment played a crucial role in shaping modern democratic ideals and scientific thought.
