War is never a pleasant experience, and some roles are particularly challenging and dangerous. While you might find yourself in tough situations regardless, there are certain roles that people have volunteered for, only to realize later why it was a bad idea. Let’s explore some of these roles and why you might want to think twice before volunteering for them.
Chemical warfare, including the use of mustard gas, became prominent during World War I. Although mustard gas was not often fatal, it caused severe chemical burns, blisters, and temporary blindness, along with long-term health issues. First used by the Germans in 1917, it was known as the “King of the Battle Gases” due to its devastating effects. The gas lingered in the environment, contaminating large areas and causing prolonged suffering for those exposed.
By the end of World War I, the full impact of mustard gas was still not well understood. Many countries conducted experiments to study its effects, often using “volunteer” soldiers. Unfortunately, many of these volunteers were not fully informed about the risks. The Chemical Warfare Service conducted tests to measure the impact of mustard gas and to evaluate protective clothing. These tests often involved minority soldiers, who later reported severe health issues like cancer and PTSD. Despite the evidence, it wasn’t until the 1990s that efforts were made to compensate these veterans for their sacrifices.
Cleaning toilets is never fun, and it’s even worse in a war setting. Stories abound of soldiers accidentally volunteering for latrine duty during boot camp. In wartime, latrines were often just pits dug near the trenches, and maintaining them was a challenging task. Those assigned to this duty had to keep these makeshift facilities as clean as possible, which was no easy feat.
Volunteering for night watch during war can be risky. Soldiers on night watch had to stay alert to potential attacks while fighting the urge to fall asleep. Falling asleep on duty could have dire consequences, such as allowing the enemy to infiltrate defenses. In 1806, the US Congress declared falling asleep on duty during wartime a capital offense. A famous case involved William Scott, who volunteered for a second night of duty and was found asleep at his post. Although sentenced to death, he was eventually pardoned.
During the world wars, women stepped up to fill roles in munitions factories, such as packing shells with TNT. This work led to their skin and hair turning bright yellow, earning them the nickname “Canary Girls.” Unfortunately, the exposure to TNT caused serious health issues, including throat problems, bone issues, and liver disease. Despite efforts to mitigate the effects, such as providing milk to drink, many women suffered from anemia and immune system damage, with over 400 deaths reported during World War I.
The Battle of Passchendaele was one of the most brutal battles of World War I, resulting in heavy casualties. Volunteer medics faced the harsh realities of war, working in casualty clearing stations close to the front lines. These medics and nurses witnessed the horrors of war firsthand, dealt with disease from infected wounds, and faced the dangers of being near the battlefield. The Red Cross reported significant losses among its members during the war, highlighting the risks faced by those who volunteered as medics.
In conclusion, while volunteering in war can seem noble, it’s essential to understand the risks and challenges associated with certain roles. History has shown that some volunteer positions can lead to severe consequences, both physically and mentally. Always consider the potential dangers before stepping forward.
Research the history and effects of chemical warfare, focusing on mustard gas. Create a presentation that explains its impact during World War I and the long-term effects on soldiers. Include information on how chemical warfare has evolved and the ethical considerations surrounding its use. Present your findings to the class.
Participate in a role-playing exercise where you are assigned different roles in a wartime scenario. Discuss and decide whether to volunteer for specific duties, such as latrine duty or night watch. Reflect on the factors influencing your decisions and the potential consequences of each choice.
Engage in a debate on the ethics of volunteering for high-risk roles during war. Consider the motivations for volunteering, the responsibilities of military leadership to inform volunteers of risks, and the long-term impact on veterans. Form teams and present arguments for and against volunteering in such roles.
Write a short story or diary entry from the perspective of a “Canary Girl” working in a munitions factory during World War I. Describe the daily challenges, health risks, and personal reflections on contributing to the war effort. Share your story with classmates and discuss the historical context.
Conduct interviews with veterans or healthcare professionals about the role of medics in war. Prepare questions about the challenges faced, the emotional and physical toll, and the importance of medical support in conflict zones. Compile your findings into a report and present it to the class.
Here’s a sanitized version of the provided transcript:
—
Why you should think twice before volunteering in war: Although war in general isn’t a pleasant place to be, there are some jobs that are just plain worse than others. For instance, being the first up a ladder during a medieval siege doesn’t exactly give you great odds of survival. And absolutely no one really wants to be responsible for running messages along the trenches. You may find yourself in the unfortunate position of doing some of these jobs regardless, but there are other roles that some people have mistakenly volunteered for and then discovered exactly why that was a terrible idea.
**Don’t volunteer to test mustard gas.** Chemical warfare using weapons like mustard gas first appeared during World War I. Mustard gas was rarely lethal, but its victims suffered severe chemical burns and blisters, were often temporarily blinded, and experienced serious long-term health effects. Introduced by the Germans in 1917 at the Battle of Ypres, it soon earned the name “King of the Battle Gases.” Although it didn’t cause the same volume of fatalities as other gases used, exposure to it required specialist medical care and caused severe damage to the respiratory system. Overall, the recovery time for its effects was much longer, and it lingered in the environment after being released, meaning large areas were contaminated—something soldiers didn’t always realize until they began to experience symptoms.
By the end of World War I, just a year later, mustard gas was still fairly new, and its health impacts were not fully understood. It was only then that the long-term effects, such as respiratory issues and eye lesions, started to emerge. Each country began to examine the effects and impact of mustard gas, one way of doing this was by recruiting “volunteer” soldiers for experimentation and testing. Despite this seeming like a test no one would willingly volunteer for, there were approximately 60,000 participants in the study. Many veterans have since spoken out about not being informed about what they were volunteering for or having been misled.
Conducted by the Chemical Warfare Service, a variety of tests were used to measure the effects of mustard gas on the volunteers, as well as tests to examine the efficacy of newly developed protective clothing. These research projects predominantly focused on whether racial disparity had anything to do with the impact of mustard gas. As a result, these so-called volunteers were often minority soldiers, and many reported effects such as cancer, eye injury, and PTSD later in life. One veteran, Rollins Edwards, reported that it felt like his skin was on fire, and many men fainted around him.
To make matters worse, there was a distinct lack of follow-up on these studies. No one properly measured the long-term effects and impact of being exposed to mustard gas during these trials. Despite evidence mounting over the decades, in the 1990s, the VA began efforts to reach veterans and offer them long-overdue benefits for their sacrifices.
**Don’t volunteer for latrine duty.** Even in the comfort of your own home, no one particularly enjoys cleaning a toilet, and this task becomes extremely unpleasant in a war setting. Anecdotes of soldiers unwittingly volunteering for latrine duty during boot camp circulate the internet, with many lamenting falling for the “any volunteers” cry from their drill sergeants. Latrines during the war were even worse, as there were no modern plumbing facilities on the front lines. If one was lucky, there were long pits dug some distance away from the trenches where soldiers could relieve themselves. The less fortunate had to use empty tins, throwing away their contents after use. Latrine trenches were maintained by personnel who were expected to keep them in as good condition as possible.
**Don’t volunteer for night watch unless you’re a night owl.** Volunteering for night watch during war can be dangerous. Tired soldiers had to contend with the potential for attacks and the need to stay alert, while also battling the urge to fall asleep on the job. In some cases, neglecting this duty could have disastrous consequences, such as exposing positions and allowing the enemy to sneak past defenses. That’s why in 1806, the US Congress made falling asleep on duty in wartime a capital offense. One notable case was that of William Scott, who volunteered for a second consecutive night of duty to relieve a fellow soldier. He was found asleep at his post, arrested, and sentenced to death, but luckily received a pardon.
**Don’t volunteer to be a “Canary Girl.”** During the world wars, many able-bodied young men were conscripted or volunteered to fight, but women also stepped up to help the war effort. With many workplaces lacking employees, women filled roles in munitions factories, such as the Royal Ordnance Filling Factory, where they worked packing shells with TNT. This resulted in curious side effects, including their skin and hair turning bright yellow, earning them the nickname “Canary Girls.” This wasn’t just a cosmetic effect; reportedly, babies born to Canary Girls during the war were also born yellow, although the color faded away. Unfortunately, many suffered long-term health effects, including throat problems, bone issues, and in severe cases, liver disease from TNT exposure. Despite being given milk to drink to combat the chemicals, the women still suffered from anemia and immune system damage, leading to over 400 deaths from TNT exposure during World War I.
**Don’t volunteer as a medic at Passchendaele.** The Battle of Passchendaele was particularly awful, resulting in heavy casualties. Poor conditions and tactics led to significant loss of life, and volunteer medics faced the harsh realities of war. In the UK military, Army nurses worked alongside Voluntary Aid Detachment (VAD) nurses at casualty clearing stations, which were only 6 to 8 miles from the front lines. As a result, nurses faced trauma from seeing the damage of war firsthand, suffered disease from infected wounds, and experienced the dangers of being so close to battle. The Red Cross estimated that across World War I, 128 nursing members, 11 general service members, and six joint war committee members were killed, with at least 100 other VADs suffering the same fate.
—
This version removes explicit language and maintains a focus on the historical context and experiences of those involved in wartime activities.
War – A state of armed conflict between different countries or different groups within a country – The war between the two nations lasted for several years, causing widespread devastation and loss of life.
Health – The state of being free from illness or injury – Maintaining good health is essential for a long and fulfilling life, as it allows individuals to engage in various activities without limitations.
Mustard – A pungent yellow or brown paste made from the seeds of a mustard plant, often used as a condiment – During World War I, mustard gas was infamously used as a chemical weapon, causing severe injuries and fatalities among soldiers.
Gas – A substance in a form like air that is neither solid nor liquid – The use of poisonous gas in warfare was banned by international treaties due to its devastating effects on human health and the environment.
Soldiers – Members of an army, especially those who are not officers – The soldiers bravely marched into battle, fully aware of the dangers that lay ahead.
Risks – The possibility of suffering harm or loss; a situation involving exposure to danger – The risks associated with smoking are well-documented, including increased chances of developing lung cancer and heart disease.
Volunteering – Freely offering to take part in an enterprise or undertake a task – Many young people are volunteering in community health programs to gain experience and contribute to society.
Medics – Medical practitioners or students, especially those serving in the armed forces – The medics worked tirelessly on the battlefield, providing critical care to wounded soldiers.
History – The study of past events, particularly in human affairs – Understanding history is crucial for learning from past mistakes and shaping a better future.
Duty – A moral or legal obligation; a responsibility – It is the duty of every citizen to stay informed about public health issues and take appropriate actions to protect themselves and others.
